At least up north around where I live manhole covers are often also either holes or bumps in the road due to things shifting around from the freeze/thaw cycles. Basically potholes with a purpose. Hitting bumps is bad for your car, so that's a pretty good reason to avoid them. Though I'd never swerve around a bump if I was going to come close to someone else, since that's much more dangerous.
post
My favorite people are those who drive giant SUVs with huge tires lifted way off the ground who do this and also slow down to 2MPH to go over train tracks.
Because I drive the same way every day. I know which ones to avoid and which ones are fine. I also have to pay to do maintenance on my car. If I can move the steering wheel a few inches for certain covers rather than spend a weekend replacing suspension, I'll do that.
In my city, they just keep paving over the old asphalt, so the manhole covers are like 6 inches deep in some places. Hitting one of those in my sedan is not pleasant.
As others have said, it's just not great for the car. Will it damage it if you hit one? Probably not. But if it's your work route or other commonly taken route, you're gonna hit it 260x in a year, and you'll own the car for multiple years. It adds up quick. Plus, they aren't always smooth to the ground or free of other pot holes and square edges. If you hit it hard enough or if it's too sharp, jagged, or deep, you can damage the wheel, the suspension, and the tire itself, easily in the thousands of dollars to repair, along with not having a vehicle for up to a few weeks.
Don't get me wrong, they shouldn't really be swerving all over the road, but dodging em when you can is nice.
Around me, they're either 2 inches below the road surface, so a giant pothole, or 2 inches above the road surface, so a giant speed bump.
The forces on your suspension can be tremendous. Repeated impacts cause faster wear. Large impacts can cause immediate damage and/or loss of control. The popularity of large wheels means the capacity of the tyres to absorb an impact is reduced, and even with larger sidewalks, tyres can be damaged by impacting a sharp edge. A single OEM rim can cost over $1000; a suspension repair is probably in the same cost range. At this time of year in frosty countries with failing infrastructure, manholes aren’t typically even close to level with the road surface and may be a significant road hazard.
Jeeps have the handling characteristics of a jeep, and hitting bumps in them is uncomfortable. “Off road capabilities” is not the same as Baja.
Because it feels horrible to drive over and if they're bad enough you can crack your rim on them
Your tire usually drops into them and this shortens the lifespan of struts, ball joints, sway bar links, control arm bushings, and potentially throws off your alignment.
Tell me, what alignment is your car?
After freezing temperatures, construction, and deferred maintenance, manhole covers can be a damaging obstruction
My car is only two years old, and the one time it needed work …. I hit one of the smaller pieces of road infrastructure - a gas valve maybe. But the pavement was broken up around it so it was a deep hole with a sharp metal edge. It destroyed my tire, a damn expensive tire
Edit to add: for my older car I just had to spend $1,500 replacing a control arm and ball joint. While there’s no way to identify a specific cause, trying to avoid obstructions is a possibility I can control
As someone who opens them regularly, because so many of the chimneys are collapsing and I regularly wonder how some haven't caved in yet.
Around here the chimneys are fine and the road around them has sunk so they stick up a couple inches above the road surface.
I've witnessed a failure like this once but it took a sunken brick crosswalk where we get frost heave into a U-shape with a flat manhole cover in the middle of one lane to get driven over for a couple years until one day the lip under the cover was so busted up it flipped the lid right out when my mom drove over it lol.
When I went to Mexico, none of them had the covers, just holes everywhere on the roads and sidewalks.
The manhole covers are lava!
In addition to frequently being a dip in the road, there are two on my way to work that make a clunking noise when I go over them and I don't like it. This has lead to a habit where I just avoid them in general.
I don't expect them to fail, it is just the noise and bumping feeling.
I would try to avoid driving over them when safely possible, because they make an annoying noise, which I wanted to spare folks living nearby from. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I drive a small car with stiff (sport) suspension. In my area manhole covers typically aren't aligned well with the road surface making them quite bumpy to drive over. This can jarring and even painful for me due to medical issues that I don't care to get into here. So I routinely avoid driving over manhole covers.
This is because people drove a street like tonnele from the 139 to the 495 (07306 to 07047) and witnessed the height issues around the manholes there.
It's PTSDriving. After surviving the doubly bifurcated and traffic-signaled tonnele traffic circle of pain, that stretch of i9 is just the next circle of hell.
I do this. Its like stepping on a crack or whatnot. I just can't handle one of my tires being on a different surface than the others. For me its definately a my brain is wierd thing.
I drive through a new area near our home everyday (in UK). Some of the manhole covers make a loud "clonk" noise when I drive over them. I avoid them because it will otherwise annoy our new neighbours. I used to live off a main road into town. There was a loose manhole cover there which drove me crazy until I managed to get the council to fix it. Probably just had stones in it making it loose.
all 50 comments