American cheese is just cheddar cheese + sodium citrate. You can make it yourself with cheddar cheese, lemon juice, and baking soda. The sodium citrate acts as an emulsifier, which prevents the cheese from separating when it melts. You can make some really high-quality American cheese, but since this is America, we have agro-businesses creating the cheapest, filler-filled shit possible
post
This is immediately and indelibly part of my worldview. Blocking and hiding any contrary comments
"Kraft" literally means "power" in German.
The burger was not an import from Germany, rather, many ground meat products were referred to by a German city name, Wiener (Wein being Vienna), Frankfurter (Frankfurt), Berliner ( US president John F Kennedy), ECT
So when they made a sandwich using a style of ground beef introduced by immigrants from Hamburg it got called a “hamburger”, but the practice of frying a ground beef patty and making a sandwich out of it is not from hamburg.
You'll never guess which German city the cheeseburger was named after
That's mighty confident!
My understanding is that there are plausible competing theories, one of which is that hamburgers were iniquity made in Hamburg.
See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_hamburger or like a book or something
The style of ground meat certainly was, but, there are no records or references to it being cooked as a patty and served as a sandwich in Hamburg.
The first references and evidence we have for it absolutely come from the US, wether it be menus, mentions in news papers, or other textual evidence.
Lots of different claims as to who did it first, but who ever it was, all the historical evidence shows that the concept originated in the US. Probably none of the people who claim to have invented it actually did, but, we do have records from the time that show the concept spreading between diners along the east coast.
I will say that sliced real Cheddar is also pretty good on burgers. The texture is different, but it doesn't ruin the cheese or anything.
Except Kraft (who emigrated to the US from Canada) patented sodium citrate stabilised cheese in 1916. This was done for logistical reasons since it didn't need refrigerated storage rather than being explicitly designed as a burger condiment. Kraft was a cheese wholesaler before he was a cheese maker.
American cheese took off in part because was used in rations for ww1 being energy dense and shelf stable.
It was also used as rations in ww2 which was due to a quirk of history before operation paperclip, which was predominantly done out of cold war paranoia.
I get that it's fun to dunk on America, but it should be possible to do so without resorting to a purely fictitious history.
Humboldt Fog is an American cheese and is my favorite fancy cheese. I hold it above French and Italian cheeses, it's freakishly good.
I would buy American Pasteurized Processed Cheese Food slices for grilled cheese sandwich or burger, but the individually wrapped slices piss me off too much. The white (not swiss) American cheese on Cuban toast is a staple breakfast here. It is delicious.
Humboldt fog is an amazing cheese but the fancy cheese place only gets it in occasionally so it's a rare treat here :<
All cheese is processed.
Funny thing is I think I like melted Swiss cheese more on my burgers.
Y'all know we have other cheeses in the states too, right?
Imagine if a chinese company made its own shitty version of tofu, and named it "chinese tofu," and then someone somewhere else concluded that all tofu in China was this shitty kind. That would be the same kind of fallacious assumption as what's going on here.
"American cheese" is more like a product category than a description of any cheese produced in America.
Just like "Canadian bacon" refers to a specific cut/style of bacon, despite most of the bacon I (a Canadian) have eaten is the kind most probably think about when they think "bacon".
I don't think I've ever had French toast from France, or Italian sausage from Italy.
And if someone didn't like Canadian bacon (can't really blame them; don't hate it but don't love it either) and concluded that all bacon produced in Canada was shitty, I can't say that I would care one way or another. Nationalistic pride never made sense to me. I don't make Canadian bacon or other bacon. That's Jim down the road (though don't tell him I don't love Canadian bacon).
all 48 comments