They should plug the hole with like, a scrap of their shirt, or a finger or whatever, and then throw the guy who drilled the hole off the boat. The problem with non-voter guy is that he isn't throwing the other guy off the boat or plugging the hole like they should be doing. I dunno though, maybe it's funny to sink the boat, I can't really judge the context of this practical joke. Are they in the middle of the ocean by some stroke of horrible luck where somehow this guy was able to drill a hole and everyone else just let him in like a crazy survival situation, and also he had a drill somehow, or are they in the middle of like, an inland lake on a fishing trip? I mean it would still be a major dick move to drill a hole in the boat, cause boats are pretty expensive even if they're just paddleboats like that, but it still might be a funny prank, I dunno, depends.
I dunno if you extend the meme more and think about it a little bit, does it get better or worse as a metaphor?