a person using AI is telling me they don’t value their own mind to the point they rather outsource it to a dumb prediction machine
Why do you believe this is so?
Most creative work is taking what we think of (an idea or thought) and putting it into action, a movie is just a more elaborate version of a story which we have been telling each other since the beginning of time
If I tell Veo3 a story and it brings the story to life with visuals and audio where have I not valued my own mind?
This feels like elitism: I had to learn a whole craft (singing/song writing/instrument etc) to bring my idea to life, you didn't use a fancy camera with fancy video editing software, you just told a computer what you'd like to see or hear, how dare you!
The reason why the original hot take is bad is because it is simply referencing all the most obvious limitations of LLM's at the time (problems with fingers, over explaining answers)
This would be like in 1995 saying smartphones?? like tiny computers that fit in your pocket? Wow that'll be so shit! Oh great so now my wrist watch computer takes 5 minutes to boot up so I can check the time? and then it'll probably blue screen of death! I bet I'll get a virus then have to run a virus scan on it ughhhhhh
tbh I might need AI to explain it to me because to me you just said: people like trash
The part I don't get is, what difference does it make (to you) if the trash is made by a guy using AI or made by a company?
The main thing is that quality movie cinema goers like yourself have an organic free range no ai involved movie experience, and so long as there is enough of you out there (and there should be) then you'll be able to enjoy your cinematography experiences while the rest of us watch slop (and ultimately isn't this what is currently happening anyway?)
Not only that but are you assuming that AI and computational power will never reach a point where we'll be able to create a wide variety of films and movies that are on par with or exceed today's movies?
Are we assuming there will never be a movie that's made using AI that is better than these:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_films_considered_the_worst
or the garbage that's on TV at 3 in the morning?