"Police could not help" Funny that
this post was submitted on 08 Sep 2024
82 points (100.0% liked)
Technology
37705 readers
292 users here now
A nice place to discuss rumors, happenings, innovations, and challenges in the technology sphere. We also welcome discussions on the intersections of technology and society. If it’s technological news or discussion of technology, it probably belongs here.
Remember the overriding ethos on Beehaw: Be(e) Nice. Each user you encounter here is a person, and should be treated with kindness (even if they’re wrong, or use a Linux distro you don’t like). Personal attacks will not be tolerated.
Subcommunities on Beehaw:
This community's icon was made by Aaron Schneider, under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 license.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
To be fair, what are they supposed to do? The phone will be handed off a bunch of times within hours of it being stolen. You are not getting your phone back unless the thieves are caught in the act.
Go knock on the door of where the find my iphone shows up
Who is to say it was at an address and not just sold/handed off in the street? They don't just take the phones to a house and pile them up, they will be sold on through fences rapidly and if they can't reset them to resell to someone, they get sold for parts (hence why this one ended up in China).
So start going after the fencing network. Make it risky to hold a stolen phone.
The phone isn’t going to end up in China from people passing them hand to hand; they’re going to be collected somewhere and bundled for shipping in an EM-protected covering of some sort. The record of the route they took right up until they go silent will be available for every phone. Looking at an aggregate map of this data should give the police a pretty good idea of what’s going on.
I suspect the difficulty is that the police need to get a data release from each individual involved and then get Google/Apple and/or the owners to voluntarily share the historical location data with the police… which most people aren’t willing to do out of an abundance of caution.
In a world of home surveillance, doorbell cameras, and phones with constant GPS that can tell you the exact location of where it's at, the police are more useless than ever.
With infinite budget sure, worth a shot, but it would cost a lot more than the price of the phone to track it down.
Realistically speaking, there isn't enough personel or funds, so it isn't worth attempting to chase the phone down. These phones move fast through fences, they aren't just taken to one address and left there. The criminals could and probably do have 'faraday bags' to block signals from phones as they move them, only ever taken out to sell them along.
All the police can do is record any data they do get and compile it into a larger investigation with the hopes of attacking the head of the snake (but what even is that?).
With infinite budget sure, worth a shot, but it would cost a lot more than the price of the phone to track it down.
Infinite budget? Bro, I know the exact location. Just go over there and knock on his door. Arrest the man and put him in jail for possession. One less thief out there taking advantage of the fact that the police doesn't enforce the fucking laws.
The criminals could and probably do have ‘faraday bags’ to block signals from phones as they move them, only ever taken out to sell them along.
They could, but they don't.
Location isn't that accurate, the phone was probably just traded in a car or in the street.
So the police get a call from the phone owner "yeah my phone location is on X street", the police get down there, then what? Let's say it was in a house, it's rows of houses in London, do they knock on every door there and ask "hey have you stolen a phone?" in hopes the guy admits it? It could have been traded already so a description of someone might not be good enough.
I just read the whole article and it just re-iterates what I have just said. They recover a small amount of the phones because of how quick they move them after they have been stolen. It even says that the criminals "wrap stolen phones in tinfoil to block its signal".
It's easy to sit in your chair and say "just go over there and arrest them", without even taking a moment to understand the logistics of tackling it.
They could do their jobs. It's not always easy but that's what they signed up for.
They are doing their jobs. but with limited manpower they have chosen not to stretch themselves even thinner by physically chasing a phone. As the article says, they try to be smarter about it.
the police say they are targeting the criminals responsible but cannot "arrest their way out of the problem". They also say manufacturers and tech firms have a bigger role to play.
Even though I fully expect the police here aren't doing as much as they could (I mean come on, are they expecting phones to come with wiimote hand straps?) , I'm at least glad their public rhetoric is that they can't "arrest their way out of the problem".
I imagine that's poor compensation when you've just had your phone snatched, however.
"Manufacturers and tech companies have a bigger role to play"
Yeah Apple is already making the parts junk with the locking but it doesn't seem to help.
If it makes economic sense to break them down for parts and locking doesn't stop it, I suppose that it might make sense to introduce security holes in phone cases, with a chain that links to a belt or similar.
Bonus -- if you're going to have a chain anyway, can maybe run a cable along it and have attached battery or other phone peripherals elsewhere on you that don't add to phone weight.
I mean this isn't surprising to anybody. plenty of luxury cars stolen over here to get shipped to the middle east
Not blaming the victim here, just glad I have different habits.
Stories like this make me glad I'm not one of those people glued to my phone 24/7.
It's way harder to snatch it when it's in your pocket.
But the fun of these stories is when someone writes an article about the thieves trying to scam the victim into giving up their codes. That's always amusing.
Yeah, let’s blame the victim.
Fair point.
Let me be perfectly clear that I think you should be able to look at your phone 24/7 without getting robbed.
Still glad I don't, though.