I don't think there's any ideology that you can unilaterally state "maximize every aspect and you'll be better, you don't need nuance". That's the entire reason why every political philosophy has myriad sects and schools of thought.
Your argument is the same one used to dismiss communism and socialism. In practice, their principles have led to bad outcomes.
It's odd to me to expect a political philosophy to have principles so precise that they don't require nuance when applying them.