119
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 29 Jul 2026
119 points (100.0% liked)
Chapotraphouse
14417 readers
454 users here now
Banned? DM Wmill to appeal.
No anti-nautilism posts. See: Eco-fascism Primer
Slop posts go in c/slop. Don't post low-hanging fruit here.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Please read the book, if you want to criticize it. In the book elves deliberately suppress technological development of men to maintain their own hegemony. And Mordor is not portrayed like some unconditional good, just as an ordinary state that was dehumanized by its enemies as part of genocidal campaign against it.
I read it and it was okay-ish, if you can tolerate high levels of libness.
Please don't make me defend this book, but it is obvious that you heard some massive misrepresentation of the plot.
!!MASSIVE SPOILERS!!
Because is a sort-of amnesiac copy of Voldemort, and this is one of the early clues.Look, I agree with you that they are pretty much techbro equivalent of priests, whose ideology revolves about justifying billionaire rule, but please don't make stuff up, when criticizing then, it is counterproductive.
i read the whole thing (eventually).
no-one here is making you defend it. if you think that plot was as "okay" as the last ring bearer then that's quite alarming to be honest and shows to me that i needn't read the last ring bearer. fascists can demonstrate a keen awareness of oppression when they want to smear an enemy. the depiction of elves and men you describe is designed to subtextually justify the ideology i described and is exactly what i'd expect.
spoiler
i didn't give a proportional description of the plot but he did befriend malffoy and join slytherin to find out fastest how magic worked so he could export it to muggle society. he spend chapters experimenting with time turners, successfully transfigures part of an eraser or something upon visualizing the matter as wavefunctions and fawning over the apollo program. he spends a chapter talking with malfoy about his weakening magic hypothesis.i promise you with my hand on my heart i didn't make up any of that besides how i depicted the hedonium swarm as lobotomies.
At this point I think we read different books.
maybe we dwelled in different circles years ago but i know TESCREAL and i know my roko's basilisks from my... basilisks.
i wouldn't be the only survivor of that cult but i and the coiner of "tescreal" are outliers. there are several neo-nazi voices in that subculture and they all get blind eyes from the rest, crusading against cluster headaches as the worst evil of all, trying to discourage "autogynephiles" of transitioning lionizing "high iq individuals" it just goes on and on before you get to "benevolent world exploders"
spoiler
(i did double-check and yes it is the same man responsible for that and the book, how do you think he feels about the us adding months or years to the singularity by embargoing perfectly good datacenter equipment because it's chinese?)