view the rest of the comments
politics
Welcome to the discussion of US Politics!
Rules:
- Post only links to articles, Title must fairly describe link contents. If your title differs from the site’s, it should only be to add context or be more descriptive. Do not post entire articles in the body or in the comments.
Links must be to the original source, not an aggregator like Google Amp, MSN, or Yahoo.
Example:

- Articles must be relevant to politics. Links must be to quality and original content. Articles should be worth reading. Clickbait, stub articles, and rehosted or stolen content are not allowed. Check your source for Reliability and Bias here.
- Be civil, No violations of TOS. It’s OK to say the subject of an article is behaving like a (pejorative, pejorative). It’s NOT OK to say another USER is (pejorative). Strong language is fine, just not directed at other members. Engage in good-faith and with respect! This includes accusing another user of being a bot or paid actor. Trolling is uncivil and is grounds for removal and/or a community ban.
- No memes, trolling, or low-effort comments. Reposts, misinformation, off-topic, trolling, or offensive. Similarly, if you see posts along these lines, do not engage. Report them, block them, and live a happier life than they do. We see too many slapfights that boil down to "Mom! He's bugging me!" and "I'm not touching you!" Going forward, slapfights will result in removed comments and temp bans to cool off.
- Vote based on comment quality, not agreement. This community aims to foster discussion; please reward people for putting effort into articulating their viewpoint, even if you disagree with it.
- No hate speech, slurs, celebrating death, advocating violence, or abusive language. This will result in a ban. Usernames containing racist, or inappropriate slurs will be banned without warning
We ask that the users report any comment or post that violate the rules, to use critical thinking when reading, posting or commenting. Users that post off-topic spam, advocate violence, have multiple comments or posts removed, weaponize reports or violate the code of conduct will be banned.
All posts and comments will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. This means that some content that violates the rules may be allowed, while other content that does not violate the rules may be removed. The moderators retain the right to remove any content and ban users.
That's all the rules!
Civic Links
• Congressional Awards Program
• Library of Congress Legislative Resources
• U.S. House of Representatives
Partnered Communities:
• News
"If it happened, it would be happening."
Ladies and gentlemen, this is what all of America has decided best represents their values and identity. Act accordingly.
"He tells it like it is!"
All of America, lol.
Correct.
It's far, far, far past the point that all the "we didn't vote for Trump" Americans take on some responsibility for this mess.
Your (overall) complacency is collectively your fault now. You have a babbling pedophile as a president who is actively destroying the world as we know it, and the best you can do is scoff at the suggestion you bear any responsibility for this.
How very American.
You're right, but they'll hate you for it
Too many of the "good" Americans have still bought into the system
They celebrate selfishness, fetishise "the grind", are materialistic and superficial
Not to mention their perverse ideas of what actually constitutes freedom...
Yep and i could give a rats ass what they think. Complacent people who grew up being told they were the best at everything
Edit: To the deleted comment "someone sounds bitter"..... yes, exactly. I am bitter. What gives you the impression I'm trying to hide that? I'm disgusted by America. That's my point. Maybe that's why you deleted it?
I'm working as hard as I can to undermine him, but I'm a disabled photographer five thousand kilometers away. What, exactly, am I supposed to do to fix this, that I'm not already doing? I'm too weak to use a gun, I'm shit at rallying forces, and besides, America is far too distributed to amass people at a single point. Even if I did somehow summon up the motor skills to outwit the Secret Service and be the best assassin in the world, I'd have to be okay with losing my wife and my friends, as I'm executed basically on the spot. I can't lose that. Trump will die before I do, and it will likely be by his own ragged mind.
Goddamm I need to get this phrase hotkeyed on my keyboard with how often I need to say it to people online who don't know how spread out the US is.
Our 5 largest cities have a nighttime pop of 1:20 of the total population. In Germany that figure is over 1:10 and in France and UK it's more like 1:5.
The largest city in the US is NYC with a nighttime population of 2.5% of the total US population, that same figure for France is 3.1% in Paris, in Germany, almost 1:20 Germans live in Berlin alone and in the UK 1:7.4 live in just London.
The US has a very small urban population for its size. This isn't to mention that the two largest cities are separated by a 2,000 mile desert and border two different oceans. The only way to congregate most Americans is through the Herculean task of mobilizing the suburbs, which has had some success (No Kings Day is the largest nonviolent protest in history), but is still much harder than rallying in more urbanocentric European countries.
I suspect that the relatively small size of European nations has made it much easier for them to have coherent protestors. The politicians have to be in physical proximity to their constituents, which puts their skin on the line if people snap. Getting enough angry people to surround bad leaders is a key ingredient to a healthy democracy.
Then you good.
Each according to thier ability.
The thing that drives the world nuts is when people in the US are like "not my responsibility".
Crazy, considering the person who spurred on this whole thread was blanket assuming that everyone in the country is allowing this to happen.
How'd you manage to miss that and then write this comment?
Haven't you heard? You have to say "I'm working as hard as I can to undermine him" in every thread you participate in, or else you're complicit with fascism. Those are the magic words. If you say them, you good (at least until the next conversation).
You might as well add it to your email signature just in case, so you won't be a target during "the revolution," as these people insist is actually going to happen.
In case you need it: /s
Yeah! I mean, not ALL men, right ladies?
Appealing to a shitty argument to try to justify your shitty argument is a strategy. Let's see if it pays off for you
(It didn't)
We're different people and I was offering another more understanding voice to the mix. You may notice my bar was actually just "anything more than just saying not my problem" which I actually thought was pretty generous and is wildly telling that even that was triggering to you.
What do you want? Me to do the sign of the cross and give a blanket absolution to all Americans on behalf of the rest of the world?
"Go, my children, your country may ravage the world I absolve you". In the name of the father the son nato UN and all humanity. I offer this to all citizens of the USA, Russia, and Israel as they decimate civilians in illegal wars. Would be kinda shitty of me to not hand it out to them too, right? I mean... what can they do about it? Not really THIER problem, right? We're all being a little judgemental by suggesting Russia get out of Ukraine or Israel out of Gaza, right? Let em in eurovision. Let em in the Olympics.
Not sure who I am to give it but if im giving that cool guy a break, I may as well give you one too, despite you being a total cunt. Not sure why you care (REALLY wish you'd introspect on that though, is it possible the uncomfort that makes you wanna lash out is that you know at some level you, as an american, are uniquely positioned to save the world like hollywood told you your whole life was your birthright, and instead you're on the internet mad at foreigners pointing out your country is mudering civilians? That discord must be HARD).
By clearly demonstrating a lack of understanding. Great, I won't bother reading the rest of this.
Where are you from?
This is a common circle for people like us to run around in.
Yes, there are many individuals who are doing a lot, punching far above their weight class.
My point is when I boycott American products, advocate for the US to be punished politically and economically, when I spread the message loud and clear where I am that "America is the enemy", that necessitates putting YOU in the crosshairs of my actions.
Do I love that? No, we're on the same team. Is that going to stop me? Absolutely not.
The best analogy I can think of is sports. I'm gonna hate your hockey team because they're our rival, they play dirty on the ice, etc. One of your players might feed the hungry and use their money to build orphanages, but that doesn't change the fact that I'll be cheering for your team to fail.
Maybe there's nothing else you can possibly do. Truly. Life's not fair. But you and I both know that the average American citizen is doing basically nothing. That's the "person" I'm talking to when I post things like this. I can't individually judge 350 million people, so I have to address your average. Your average sucks.
I am prepared to die in this country.
I do not deserve to die in this country, I don’t choose to live here.
But because I am transgender, my federal government explicitly wants me dead.
And the populations of other countries do not care for my survival, because I was born on an overseas American military base, and then brought here as a child, means I am a citizen of this evil empire.
And I understand that even though I myself am not evil, I am a member of an evil empire, and my government and large portions of the outside world want me injured or dead in some way.
But I am scrappy and I have a heart full of love and beauty.
And I outlived Charlie Kirk.
versus
Notice the difference? Me neither.
How fucking stupid does one have to be to equate boycotting US brands and launching a fucking tomahawk missile at an elementary school. Jesus. Fucking. Christ.
Let's back up a bit for those with selective amnesia. This is how this comment chain started:
If you don't see how the exact same logic is at play, then I can't help you. Equivalent logic structures (invalid though they be) doesn't imply equal severity, and I'm tired of the disingenuous argument that it does.
Like the classic: "I'm suffering" "NO YOU'RE NOT, BECAUSE I'M SUFFERING MORE!!!!!"
Let me guess, you probably also think every German is a nazi and every Jew is a zionist? Cause that's the same kind of generalization you're making. The same kind of fallacy that the US and Israel have weaponized to rationalize murdering civilians across the middle east.
As a human, I love you.
Maybe it's on me, but after comparing boycotting mcdonalds to a literal war crime... to come back by trying to convince me to cut Nazi Germany some slack.
You do you. I always say to people now, that you never now need to guess what you'd have done if you were in nazi Germany, it's whatever you're doing now.
I don't expect everyone to have taken a Crack at hitler. Or to have sabotaged a fuel truck. Or have sheltered a Jew.
But, apparently, what YOU would have done is write scathing rebuttals to the Allies who were critical of the bystanders. You would have been arguing that the rest of the world was asking too much of the German people.
When did I say anything about cutting nazi Germany slack? Is that how you interpret questioning whether you think every German is a nazi? Cause if so you either need to work on your reading comprehension, or get over your teutophobia.
Plenty of people in nazi Germany were against the regime. They couldn't leave much of a public record, for obvious reasons, but they were there. There was a German resistance, but it didn't last very long before getting crushed.
What you're arguing is essentially that the Allied forces making their way through Germany should have been roughing up civilians, because they were Germans and apparently, according to you, that makes them nazis.
That is a terrible argument, and fortunately one that most sane people reject outright. But you're making it here about USians, many of whom don't support the current administration.
Focus all your ire on the administration, on trump supporters and the entire maga movement, on congressional republicans, on supreme court conservatives, on billionaire oligarchs and the right-wing media, hell even on DINO spoiler voter members of congress and the complacent, centrist, and corporatist leadership of the democratic party. You'll get no argument from me there.
But to accuse the entire US population? That's no different than blaming the civilians living under any other dictatorship, and if you continue to insist that you're in the right for doing so then you can kindly fuck off.
Where have i suggested anything even remotely similar to the allies roughing up the German citizenry? Violence at all?
I get that you're mad. For some reason you're desperate for someone to acknowledge you're "one of the good ones" or something.
First of all, that is pathetic, period.
If it makes you feel any better, I'm sure your identity is multifaceted. And, ultimately, I pass no judgement on you as a complete human. I'm unsatisfied by your comprehension of your own situation. Im unsatisfied by your comprehension of the world. I'm unsatisfied at your ability to read. Im unsatisfied by your capacity for first order logic. I think you are very thin skinned.
But you're passionate. You write well. You say "fuck". You have an instinct to "defend" your "kin". You don't know when to quit. You're obviously incredibly optimistic. I admire and respect all of those things about you.
People are multidimensional. I don't think you're a bad guy. Nothing you've said makes me think you're great or anything, but like... you're allowed in my house?
It starts with demonization. If you don't see the direct line between demonizing an entire populace and acts of violence being committed against them, then I don't know what else to tell you. Are we suppose to wait for egregious acts of violence to occur before we can call out prejudice?
Your plausible deniability that you're relying on is the same thing stochastic terrorists rely on to maintain their innocence. "I didn't kill that person! I only put their address online and said they were an asshole!"
No, you're again missing the point entirely. I don't need you to acknowledge me as "one of the good ones," because I categorically reject your offhand generalization and vilification of the entire populace. I'm telling you that you're wrong; not begging for your approval.
Get this through your head: I DON'T NEED TO SATISFY YOU!
I don't owe you anything. I don't need to prove myself to you. I don't need to demonstrate my comprehension to you. I'm not obliged to you in any way, and you're not entitled to make demands upon me that I do. You're judging without knowledge, which is the definition of prejudice.
I'M NOT IN YOUR FUCKING HOUSE.
Well said. Very well said.
The complacent public in Germany were absolutely at fault. The complacent public in Israel were absolutely at fault.
Not every American is MAGA, but every American that just shrugs and says "I've got bigger fish to fry" while they can absolutely do more is absolutely at fault.
Red line after red line after red line and no real resistance? Cowards.
Tell me, what will you do when Trump is not removed in November after elections (if they even happen)? When your illusion of your checks and balances saving you finally falls apart completely? You have 5 months left. Maybe spend some time thinking about that.
Uh the difference is being anti-American is clearly and objectively the correct stance and your country brought it on yourselves.
Iran's government are no saints, but they sure as shit aren't the aggressors in this situation. So fuck off, it is not remotely the same
Sure, you can be against the US government, especially the current administration. I'm against the current administration. I voted against them. Stop trying to pin responsibility on people who don't even support what's happening.
The US/Israeli of Iran was illegal and uncalled for, and I'm firmly opposed to it. No one here is saying otherwise. We're saying that you generalizing the actions of the US government to the entire population, despite widespread disapproval, is wrong. And it's no different than someone blaming the people of Iran for the actions of the regime. Those people didn't deserve to die. Most of them were protesting against their own government.
In both cases, the issue is prejudice. And you can't deflect from that by making strawman arguments against points that I'm not even making.
If the people of Iran were as complacent as the American people I would blame them too.
They've been far, FAR braver than Americans, and in the face of way more brutal oppression. And for a long time too. I would never compare the Iranian people to the American people. That would be a huge insult to the Iranian people.
That's interesting, cause you seem like the type that was accusing the Iranian protestors of being CIA plants.
Yeah, I've supported the New Iran movement since it first hit my radar in 2022 when Mahsa Amini was killed.
The thing is, I didn't compare the Iranian people to the American people. I compared your logic to the trump logic.
It must've gone right over your head for you to extract that nugget from it. And your continuance to try to deflect by mischaracterizing what I'm saying is nothing more than a strawman.
How very Canadian to think your shit doesn't stink.
On the contrary, that's just how an American who felt uneasy about their personal efforts would react to this.
To my recollection the leader of my country is not a literal con man, pedophile and blithering idiot but sure, bang your fists like a typical American and see how much it helps.
Right, must be convenient to make blanket generalizations about everything. Reminds me of a particular group... oh right! MAGAts. Imagine being so closely aligned with a group of malignant tumors.
You've earned your tag, good luck.
Meh, MAGA can't be that bad. They've literally hijacked your government and it's not really a big deal so.... guess it's not too bad to get lumped in with them right?
Wrong.
Uhhh there's a lot there, are you just saying it's all wrong? Do you want to share with the class?
Edit: They did not.
Fuck off and learn how democracies work
Oh I'm sorry, is your working democracy in the room with us right now?
You want to try to make explain how that connects to blaming everyone including the ones who voted against this, or are your mental gymnastics not that good?
Sure I will make explain you good!
You didn't vote against this. You voted against Trump and a whole lot of things you worried might happen if he won.
You voted against him hoping that someone else would win.
They didn't, and now a whole lot of bad shit is happening now that wasn't on the table when you voted. Not as anything more than "maybe he'll do these bad things if he wins"
Your fucking vote doesn't buy you 4 years of "this isn't my problem I didn't ask for this". Who the fuck raised you all to feel this way?
Good for fucking you, you didn't vote for him. Good for you you went to a protest once or twice.
It is June 5, 2026. The president of the United States is a convicted felon, a confirmed rapist, pretty much a guaranteed pedophile, he has protected people who have done these things, he has a fucking fund for traitors to thank them for their efforts to destroy your democracy.
I feel like, and I know I'm not alone in this feeling as a non American, fucking Frank Grimes. Homer is Trump, Springfield is America. You're literally driving the rest of the world insane with your idiocy.
You don't have to convince me that he's a piece of shit, I already agree with you there. Where you go wrong is by trying to insist that this is somehow my fault, as if I'm somehow personally to blame for this.
You don't know what goes through my mind on a typical day. The depression, the despair, the disillusionment, the frustration, the outrage, the indignation, or anything else. And I don't have to sit here and tell you about all that as if you're my therapist.
You don't know how I live my life, what I do to get by, to survive day-to-day. You don't know how or when or what I do to participate in the collective resistance, or what measures I have to take to protect myself while doing so. And I don't have to tell you about any of that.
I don't have to explain myself to you, and I don't have to justify myself to you. You're a prejudiced bigot, and I guess that's just the way you're gonna be.
You do share collective blame for this. Sorry pal. If you can't understand the difference between collective blame and me saying you, specifically, have failed, then I don't know what to tell you.
Climate change. I've done far more than my fair share vs my responsibility, but I still accept that I'm part of the failure that my kids have to live with.
I'm not sure why it's so hard for Americans to understand this. My best guess is the pure, mainlined indoctronation of individualism and exceptionalism that disgusts a good chunk of the world.
Just go fuck yourself. That's the only thing worth saying to you anymore.
Stay classy!
Like this?