765
ICE is as American as Apple Pie
(thelemmy.club)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 05 Feb 2026
765 points (97.6% liked)
Memes
55471 readers
782 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 7 years ago
MODERATORS
People don't want literal genocide on Statesians. What people want is the end of the US Empire, including the state, ideally via socialist revolution. I also want the end of Israel as a state, and I want Russia to have a socialist revolution. It's important to read into what people are actually meaning by their words, and not take it to mean that they want to kill you personally, unless you're fighting to uphold imperialism.
I myself am a Statesian, and have no intention on dying.
That's a charitable take but when people say they support Donald Trump because he "threatens US hegemony" while not acknowledging:
It makes it ring very hollow. Because if your goal was to replace it with technofuedalism we're on track.
People don't support Trump "because he threatens US Hegemony." Celebrating the decline in hegemony is not the same as supporting Trump or the damage the empire deals.
Means to an end, got it. So be it, If things end up as bad as you seem to predict I hope you can rebuild something from the smoldering ashes. I'll still try my hand at organized resistance.
No? I do org work IRL for the purpose of establishing socialism. Being happy that the empire is losing its iron grip on the world doesn't mean I try to make things worse to do so.
It's like you're intentionally taking the most bad-faith reading possible.
You're right I conflated your opinions with those I have argued with the past on ML and for that I apologize.
However, If you think this ends when America dies that's wishful thinking, the oligarchy is as comfortable in Russia, India or Brazil as it is in America and they seem to be shifting as they see the writing on the wall.
None of those 3 countries have the finance capital required to replace the US Empire. What makes the US Empire unique is its total hegemony. Europe comes close financially, but doesn't have the hard power to keep that going when the US Empire falls.
That wouldn't be true for long when they migrate their capital as we've seen already happening with recent market ripples.
How so? Finance capital doesn't shift that quickly, nor does industrial capacity.
I think it could, look how rapidly China industrialized, how rapidly India industrialized, when given a centralized power structure and lack of regulations It's been shown to be possible. Now it wouldn't happen overnight which is why I believe it's already underway and why they're investing so heavily in destabilizing Germany, The UK and India.
I believe by migrating their capital to European defense contractors and advancing far right policy they are readying an escape hatch
India is lagging far behind China, the reason China developed so rapidly is due to their socialist market economy. By having strong central planning, and public ownership of the large firms and key industries, while allowing limited private and foreign capital for secondary and small/medium industries. As a consequence of this structure, it is neither imperialist nor driven to imperialism. These other countries you speak of cannot replicate China's success without adopting socialism anyways, which prevents the drive to imperialism.
So, if I understand you correctly you're asserting that the dissolution of the American power structure would disallow oligarchy for asserting centralized control and would force them to have a much smaller sphere of influence as is seen with Russian and The Saudi Arabian Oligarchs?
The "oligarchy" in the US already has control. The dissolution of the current, capitalist system would result in either socialism if we succeed or barbarism if we fail, and said barbarism would be far more localized. Russia dissolved a socialist system, not an oligarchic one of capitalism, and Saudi Arabia is a monarchy.
I was using the broad term oligarch to mean someone who has " great capital and political control who is not part of the electorate". It's okay though, I still gather what you mean.
I still think you underestimate the blood price if things have to be done that way but it sounds like we agree on most things just not how easy it is to rip out the parasite that is capitalism.
That's generally been my point, I think you actually agree with most people here, but have been reading them less charitably.
It was too long ago for me to pull up the specific comment but I have had people on ML showing me Al Jazeera articles trying to convince me that DT is good for the Gaza strip and that he was a better vote than Kamala so for now I'll evaluate on a case by case basis.
The majority opinion seems to be that neither would stop the genocide, both would carry it out.
Agreed, Israel has too much control and is too interwoven with US foreign influence for either to stop it. Maybe if Mamdani ever made it to the big chair but we both know that will never happen as long as the DNC exists as it currently does.
Israel is not controlling the US, the US controls Israel. Israel has some counter-influence, but the US uses Israel to secure its interests in the region. Stopping it requires hitting imperialist profits directly.
I would have said yes in 2016 but since 2022 Netanyahu seems to exert considerable influence even when the electorate try to slow them down for fear of backlash. Now Israel does advance US foreign policy but I don't think Netanyahu is so tight on that leash, I believe he's doing it for the love of the game, so to speak.
Israel is a settler-colony. Total colonization of Palestine is its necessary end, which breeds resistance. The US supports it because Israel is a US millitary base at a country scale.
I agree with the structural point about Israel's role as a client state/base. My point is that within that structure, Netanyahu's government has become a highly volatile and agentic client, one that can create crises that even its patron struggles to manage. This changes the tactical landscape for opposition.
There's definitely counter-influence, but it doesn't outweigh the US's influence is my point.
No you didn't. You're making that up.
Why does this guy always show up to say that? Also here's one I'll always disagree with mostly because he only shows up to be a contrarian so they wouldn't let me agree if I wanted to.
Lol, clearly you've been caught lying before
I ain't digging back through 15 months of comments to go find it. But is it really so unbelievable to you that a single person on your forum could have a bad opinion?
It's a bit of an insane, take isn't it?
What are you even talking about?
Seems a pretty clear thread to me but it's all good, have a nice night.
Go back to Reddit
No, I'm good here thanks, as a fun thought exercise have you ever considered being pleasant to be around.
Go back to reddit
Things generally get worse with every election, especially when Republicans win, but just because ICE didn't boast about its terror under Democrats it doesn't mean people weren't kidnapped, even children. ICE funding increased constantly even under Democrats.
Economic sanctions imposed by the US kill over half a million a year. Do our deaths count less because we're abroad? Your government has been terrorizing the global south ever since it was capable of it. I know people who lost relatives under the last US backed dictatorship in Argentina. My grandparents lost several friends, disappeared, taken away.
We don't have the patience to treat all of you with silk gloves. But no, the vast majority of us don't desire your civilian population to be terrorized, we don't want more war, we want you out of our countries so we can organize and develop and be sovereign. And believe it or not, terrorizing us is and has always been bipartisan.
I understand that FPTP forces them into a lesser evil dichotomy that makes progress incremental and back sliding torrential. A flaw that's also getting exploited in Canada.
I'm no fan of their foreign policy either and it seems for the post part we agree then. My apologies for the misunderstanding.
All good, hope you have a good weekend