52
Did the CIA Conclude That Stalin WASN'T a Dictator?
(www.youtube.com)
Welcome to c/history! History is written by the posters.
c/history is a comm for discussion about history so feel free to talk and post about articles, books, videos, events or historical figures you find interesting
Please read the Hexbear Code of Conduct and remember...we're all comrades here.
Do not post reactionary or imperialist takes (criticism is fine, but don't pull nonsense from whatever chud author is out there).
When sharing historical facts, remember to provide credible souces or citations.
Historical Disinformation will be removed

The thumbnail of the first video is just clickbait, with the conclusion at the end of the video being that Trotsky wasn't right or completely vindicated about everything and that Trotsky and Stalin both used the history of the Soviet Union as a weapon for political and ideological orthodoxy.
Here's the transcript of that conclusion
I just finished the first video and, knowing nothing about any of this, I'd like to be pointed towards the direction of any refutation or criticism of the contents of the video.
I guess I don't know the first thing about Trotsky.
Yeah Lenin totally hated the guy he asked to help him commit assisted suicide. Not like that's the kind of thing you ask the person you're closest to when you can't ask your wife to do it. (Stalin refused btw)
Oh! So this is the famous "testament of Lenin" I've heard about. I guess I actually need to read about it.
Honestly, it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things because Lenin wasn't King of the Bolsheviks. He might have wanted Trotsky, but the Party wanted Stalin. And no single person, even someone as brilliant as Lenin, trumps the will of the Party. This is democratic centralism.
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
Trotsky gets uncritically dogged on more than any other leftist I've ever heard of, not that he's above criticism but it's just kind of embarrassing how knee jerk most opinions of him/ his politics are
To be fair, from an economic standpoint, Trotsky would have been disastrous for the USSR.
Trotsky thought that FDR’s New Deal would bankrupt America lol. And this is the guy who advocated for a rapid, planned industrialization while criticizing the NEP, but also believe that you cannot run large deficit for rapid expansion of industrial base while maintaining full employment.
Stalin, on the other hand, figured out exactly how to do that without relying on foreign capital or lowering workers wages (as Deng’s reform did) with his Five Year Plans, in a country torn apart by a devastating civil war with much of their wealth already looted.
One could even argue that without Stalin’s timely FYPs that started in 1929, it would be unlikely for the USSR to industrialize in time to resist Nazi invasion. In fact, the Germans themselves were surprised by how fast the Soviets could churn out entire mechanized divisions during the invasion itself.
I always joke that if Deng, by chance or by life circumstances, had arrived at the USSR just a few years later in 1930-31, so instead of witnessing the NEP, he would have seen what the first, early stage of FYP looked like, his later reform in China could very well have taken a radically different turn.
He got one thing right about the CPC out of pure contrarianism against Stalin saying the CPC should self-liquidate, and Trots have been riding that coattail ever since.
30% of my knee-jerk anti-Trotsky feelings come from how insufferable he was and 70% come from how insufferable Trotskyists tend to be.
There's far worse crimes than being insufferable, though-- worthy of actual criticism. Like actively trying to undermine and sabotage a precarious revolution.
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
Ahhhh
Re the 2nd video:
I figured as much, but that doesn't mean absolutely everything this person says is bunk.