this post was submitted on 07 Sep 2024
39 points (100.0% liked)

Geopolitics

301 readers
5 users here now

The study of how factors such as geography, economics, military capability and non-State actors affects the foreign policy of states.

All articles will require a short submission statement of 3-5 sentences.

Use the article title as the submission title. Do not editorialize the title or add your own commentary to the article title.

In this community we encourage long, in-depth submissions. Submissions should not be news articles that merely provide quick updates on current events; instead they should include background information and an explanation as to why the events they describe are occurring.

Submissions should not be about an individual country's domestic policies. Instead, they should be about relationships between different countries and/or relevant international organizations. Things like breakaway politics are permitted in this subreddit, as they are relevant to and could affect the geopolitical system.

Submissions are strongly encouraged to come from reputable sources. When posting from a lesser known source, please check whether the authors have some sort of qualification demonstrating they are knowledgeable of the subjects they discuss.

Sources that include (or solely contain) maps, statistics, or other multimedia (videos, interviews, primary sources, etc.) are permitted and even encouraged in this subreddit.

We encourage discussion and welcome anyone to pose hypotheses and ask questions. We allow self-posts.

We encourage comments to be cited.

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Illegal stuff has been happening on Telegram since forever.

Don't get me wrong. I am not saying that I've discovered the true machinations behind the arrest. Just bouncing my ideas.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago) (1 children)

Do you think that the arrest of the Telegram CEO was justified? Just curious.

Is Telegram at least better than most comms out there?

[–] [email protected] 10 points 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago) (1 children)

I don't think it's justified, for various reasons- first there's the blatant hypocrisy and double standards, then there's that holding a platform responsible for everything done on it is also ridiculous- and what they were asking from Telegram is honestly IMO even "worse" than what China and Russia does (not that I think Chinese or even Russian control/censorship is necessarily bad- and I agree with the necessity of such controls for any sovereign state), as they are trying to impose backdoors, discretely, on a global platform, rather than simply being open about it and keeping it within their own borders.

That said, from what little I do know of Durov- he strikes me as having been at least a bit of a smug liberal shitlord before, who was basking in the praise of the west over squabbles with the Russian govt. over much, much lesser things, to my understanding. I can't say it's not at least a bit funny/ironic- unjustified as it may be for many reasons (hypocrisy and secondary motives, typical western posturing their laws to have some sort of global suzerainty, blatant attempts at expanding the surveillance/propaganda state with this likely being particularly motivated by trying to crack down on coverage of the genocide in Gaza). He thought he was living it up in the "free" west, but then it turned out that the "enlightened garden" was actually worse and more demanding and tyrannical than Russia (or China for that matter- China wouldn't have been demanding he crackdown on users outside the Great Firewall, or demanding he add a backdoor) would ever have been...

Past that, the Durov "arrest" (kidnapping as I see it- they did it to get leverage on his brother I assume, he himself can't even give them what they are asking, he's just a hostage) holds many similarities with that of Meng Wanzhou's, tbh. The US is trying to maintain a monopoly (that is primarily challenged by TikTok and Telegram), and they're kidnapping people to do it.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 1 week ago

And a "rival" bourgeois, no less.

Yes, well, Meng Wanzhou was able to get free; wondering if Durov has more of a chance than she did, given that she was able to be exonerated and leave, correct me if I'm wrong.