this post was submitted on 15 Feb 2024
24 points (100.0% liked)

transenby_liberation

2210 readers
1 users here now

Community for trans and non-binary folk to band together and break free from the oppressive shackles of cis-heteronormative capitalism. Or shitpost and converse with each other. Just stay comfy, y'all. :)

Asking trans and non-binary related questions is highly encouraged by our community, but please direct all questions to c/askchapo. <3


EDUCATIONTransgender Liberation: A Movement Whose Time Has Come by Leslie Feinberg

Trans Liberation: Beyond Pink or Blue by Leslie Feinberg
Trans Liberation Chapo Discussion

Stone Butch Blues by Leslie Feinberg

Transgender Warriors: Making History from Joan of Arc to Dennis Rodman by Leslie Feinberg

Whipping Girl by Julia Serano

Feminism for Babies


RESOURCES

Hudson's FTM Resource Guide

Transgender Map by Andrea James

r/asktransgender wiki


RULES

1. Familiarize yourself with the Code of ConductCode of Conduct

2. Don't link to transphobiaPlease don't link to transphobia (or other bigotry), even if your personal intent is to challenge the bigotry in some way. Provide a content warning label in the title of your post where applicable.

3. Be dank; don't be not-dankNo liberalism, capitalist apologia, imperialism, etc.

4. No sexually explicit contentAs badly as some of us want to get saucy here, do not post sexually-explicit content that could reveal your personal or confidential information. Until there is a way this could be safely executed, all sexually-explicit posts will be removed to keep our comrades safe.

5. We are not a crisis serviceWe can't guarantee an immediate response. This does not mean no one cares. If you need to talk to someone at once, you may want to take a look at this directory of Hotline Numbers.

6. If you need help but don't feel comfortable making a post for any reasonplease message the moderators. We will be glad to talk with you privately, or help in any other way that we can.

founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Introduction

This journey is dedicated to the tremendous healing, vitality, creativity, and passion embodied in queer people. It is a journey of self-discovery for people who believe life beyond the cishet norm is a cause for celebration! You are beautiful. You are worthy of love and no matter how alienated and oppressed we are by capitalism, we have the duty to give it to ourselves. Queer self-love is resistance to capitalism.

This group is a guided journaling practice for queer people to work towards self-acceptance, self-understanding and empowerment to live openly. I intend to explore my gender identity, but this group is open to cis people looking for greater security in non-heterosexual sexuality. The framework is loosely adapted from the book 'Gay Spirit Warrior' by John R. Stowe. Pacing and overall structure is at the discretion of the group!

Week 2: Early Beliefs

This week is dedicated to examining the origins of our internalized beliefs about sexuality and gender & killing the cop inside our head (reprogramming our inner critic). Take them at the pace that makes sense for you! Also please reach out to support and help other people reflect and interpret their own answers. This is meant to be personal reflection but also community building.

IntroductionWhen we're young, we unreservedly look to adults to tell us about life. "This is a tree. The color of the sky is blue. You are a woman. Woman like men." and so on. These words and the wider world are a mirror we search dilligently for what it tells us about ourself. Unfortunately for most queer people, the mirror is often warped and skewed. If we were very lucky, we had some of our family to support us, a lesbian aunt to serve as a role model, or a trans neighbor to show us 'hey its something else out here!'

But most of us aren't that lucky, and not even the most supportive family can change the messages of the patriarchal culture at large.

Most of the messaging we receive supports the belief that we are broken or flawed in some way. Even as we start to accept ourselves, much of this messaging lives on as internalized queerphobia.

As we begin journalling this week, you might ask "why stir up old negatives?" The answer is that these beliefs are the underpinning of our internalized ideology around queerness. Because they act as a mental filter to our perceptions, our beliefs end up being self-fulfilling. This is true regardless of whether we have conscious awareness of them or not, but only through conscious awareness can we begin to struggle against corrosive beliefs.

Just about everyone has some amount of internalized negative beliefs. Let's get empowered and liberate ourselves from them! Take the initiative to hunt out the negatives! Actively shape your beliefs!

Dare to struggle, dare to win! Gay is good!

Early Beliefs

Exercise 1: Unconcious Negatives—Taking Inventory

A) 'Being Queer is...' We're going to start by trying to examine our unconscious beliefs about queerness. Using whatever language makes the most sense to you, label a notebook page or word document 1-10 then complete the sentence 'Being Queer is...'. If queer isn't how you describe yourself, use what language fits best.

Write as quickly as you can and put down whatever comes up. Your mind will try to edit every word to make your responses acceptable. You're looking for what your really believe, which won't always be positive, consistent, or affirming. The best way to beat your inner censor is to write so quickly you don't have time to think. If you're really spitting, keep going after the tenth sentence!

B) 'Because I'm Queer, I can't....' Repeat the exercise above, this time using the sentence 'Because I'm Queer, I can't....'

When you finish, read the lists over. Put a mark by each statement you consider negative. Resist the urge to judge or critique yourself. Just because you harbor negative thoughts, you are not a bad person or queerphobic! Uncovering your hidden negatives will allow you to push past them.

Exercise 2) Role Models

Take a little while to reflect on your life and your early queer role models. Where did you learn what it meant to be gay, to be bi, to be ace, to be trans?

Kill the Cop in your Head! Retraining your Inner CriticOften, internalized queerphobia takes on a life and voice of its own. For this discussion, we will personify this voice as your Inner Critic. For most people, the Inner Critic is maladaptive adaptation to protect us from the perceived dangers of being queer. This is what is operative when we tell ourselves things like 'that guy will never like you because...' or 'I'll never be a real ____ because of my ____'

Your Inner Critic fights dirty. Because they know you so well, they will always hit below the belt. Their accusations are usually slippery—vague enough to be hard to disprove, while containing enough (perceived) truth to feel weighty.

When we were young, we learned to maintain a high degree of vigilance in self-defense to protect us from social pressure or violence for our deviance from patriarchal gender and sexual norms. Deep inside, we record every correction or reprimand aimed at us from peers, parents, and other authority figures. We learned to watch out and police how we held our bodies, how our eyes lingered, how our voices sounded.

This vigilance may have helped us survive, but it can also inhibit us from living in liberated queer joy and self-acceptance. As Mao exhorts us 'No investigation, no right to speak'. In the first exercise, we will begin by examining our self-critical beliefs. In the second, we will begin their re-education.

Exercise 1) Taunt the Critic Out This one works best on paper. On a blank page, draw a column that takes up a third of the page. In the larger part, begin writing some variation of the following affirmation at least ten times 'Being Queer is natural and good.' If this statement doesn't make your heart jump with excitement, revise it to one that resonates with your goals and journey.

As you write, over and over as quickly as you can, listen to what starts bubbling up in the back of your mind—comments, rejections, protests, criticism, editorializing. You might hear 'yeah, right' or 'so what? I'll never fit in even if I embrace this.' Whatever comes up, write it immediately in the right-hand column and keep trucking. Don't judge or argue. Just get as much down as you can.

When you finish, compare what's left with your unconcious negatives from the previous exercise and see what patterns come up or what statements are really striking or cutting. These are the most incisive statements your Inner Critic uses to control/inhibit you.

If time permits, spend some time trying to interrogate where each of these statements come from. Did someone tell you these things growing up? Did you read it? Don't worry if there isn't an answer for some of these. You don't need to find the origin to release them, but the insight can be helpful!

The goal of this exercise is not to find someone to blame, but to examine and release—ultimately you are the person carrying these beliefs

Alternate mantra suggestions I am a trans man and that is beautiful. Ace is good. I love my queer soul.

Exercise 2: Write Your Own Script A key step in escaping the Inner Critic is to create an alternative, liberatory framework from their oppression.

Let's assemble beliefs that support us to supplant our internalized queerphobia. Begin by writing "I'm willing to replace negative beliefs with new ones that support my actualization and queer joy."

Similar to how we reframed our challenges as goals in week one, come up with a positive alternative to each of the core critiques brought up in your early beliefs or investigation into your Inner Critic. For example, I struggle with the belief "I will never embody real femininity." I am working to supplant this belief with the belief "My femininity is an authentic and real part of myself (whether or not I feel safe to express it)".

Make your new words enthusiastic and positive. Add any positive beliefs that came up earlier to the new list you are forming. Read the list aloud to yourself. How does it make you feel? If you need to revise anything, do it now!

ConclusionBe patient with yourself. Letting your new scripts supplant your self-criticism and internalized queerphobia takes time. Making your affirmations a working part of your consciousness and understanding takes time and effort.

Two factors help us install these new ideas more effectively. The first is repetition of the new mantras. Try to make time to actively reflect and apply the new beliefs to your self understanding. Repeat the affirmations you developed to yourself. The second, remember that the part of our mind we are accessing is not rational. While we can logically understand and apply a queer liberatory framework, we need to have grace for when it is not fully internalized.

Be creative! Be playful and silly in finding ways to practice the new beliefs you are working to build and instill into yourself. Make little posters, Make songs. Look in the mirror and hit on yourself if that's your thing.

Optional Exercise: Policing the Cop in Your HeadThis exercise is intended to help you realize how superficial and repetitive your inner policeman is. Create a dedicated space (digital or on paper) to record what your Inner Critic is saying. Then whenever you notice that you're self-bashing, acknowledge the Critic. "Oh, hi Critic. Back on the bullshit? So, whaddya gotta say this time?"

Give them their say. In your running Critic's Corner, write down whatever it wants to tell you. You don't have to believe it. After the first few times, you'll see the the Critic is pretty much a broken record. Instead of writing out what it has to say each time, you can just put a tally next to the relevant passage from the last time. The Critic is a paper tiger! Putting it under the spotlight will let you see how flimsy it is.

In the spirit of TC_69, I love my trans and queer comrades! trans-heart

top 9 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 7 points 8 months ago
[–] [email protected] 6 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago) (1 children)

These exercises were difficult and helpful, thank you trans-heart

One of the things that became quickly apparent to me was the continuation of my whole "rules for me but not for thee" internalized BS. It makes it very difficult to see what is internalized transphobia/queerphobia/etc. and what is deeply negative self conception. For example, the cop in my head doesnt say "trans people cant be beautiful/pretty/attractive", rather, he says "you cant be beautiful/pretty/attractive". But is this judgement a result of self hatred alone? Or (more likely) is it the result of internalized transphobia coupled with a deep seated feeling/understanding that it is unacceptable to say something negative about another person, so the entire weight of the judgement gets turned onto myself as the only internally consistent and valid target? badeline-rage madeline-scared gun-hubris I guess another way to say it would be 'is he saying "you cant be beautiful/pretty/attractive" or "you cant be beautiful/pretty/attractive (because you're not cis)"?'.

Anyway, thank you for doing these journaling posts. This one was upsetting but in a probably healthy way. The only way out is through (insert chorus from "the wheel" here) cat-trans

[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago) (1 children)

I'm glad it was helpful for you & proud of you for sticking through it. Out of curiosity, what mantra did you choose and what were your new beliefs for 'flip the script'?

is it the result of internalized transphobia coupled with a deep seated feeling/understanding that it is unacceptable to say something negative about another person, so the entire weight of the judgement gets turned onto myself as the only internally consistent and valid target

This really resonated with me! You articulated it really clearly. I think powering through and making that connection could be the best way to let go of this belief. Once you are able to admit you think 'I can't be beautiful/pretty/attractive because I'm trans.' you open up with the direct contradiction with your currently more intellectual/cerebral belief that trans is beautiful. You can't maintain that contradiction permanently and you've removed the coping mechanism. Without that mechanism, the only channel your mind can take is to accept 'trans is beautiful and that means me too!'

[–] [email protected] 3 points 8 months ago

This got more rambly than I thought, sorry.

Im holding and trying to carry forward with me the mantra of "I am beautiful because Im trans". Im trying to extend that more cerebral belief downwards, and invert the deeper feelings of my transness disqualifying me from any form of beauty. Just like trying to carry the beliefs towards each other so they can meet. and tbh I think once Ive addressed the major dysphoria points on my face it will be easier to extend that mantra to "I am attractive. Full stop". I know I will never fit the societal standard of "pretty", but that doesnt matter cause society is hateful and built on agressively contracted/shrunken colonial standards of beauty and gender. I have a lot of good beliefs in that cerebral space, i just need to bring them deeper. It also reveals to me the ways my familys weird body dismorphia stuff impacted my view of myself and whats acceptable, but thats a whole other conversation.

Ive also really been kinda inspired by a comment from Othello and a post from Cromalin about just being like "Im cute!", and bringing that from yourself to yourself. Idk, i struggle with feeling like a toy, like, i get taken out of my box, played with, and out back in my box, and I dont have actual desires of my own. So a sort of side-project of sorts is working on accepting that I can and do want to be cute and that cuteness is a state of mind that I can carry with me wherever I am and whatever I look like.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago (1 children)

I do not have a cop in my head. I have a fully militarized police force, and they are currently putting down a riot.

Been doing a lot of experimenting lately. Been calling myself genderqueer because it's vague enough to encompass what I experience. Something new is that I asked my wife to call me she/her sometimes. That's new for me.

Sometimes I feel like I want to be a woman so strongly. Other times, I genuinely enjoy being a man. Not like, it's comfortable for me, but real enjoyment. Not being able to just choose and do both causes me some pain.

Skip this next part if you want to avoid my brainworms.

reactionary self talkI just can't imagine referring to myself as bigender or gender fluid. I know it's reactionary, but I feel like it's a childish thing. I can't imagine me, a grown ass person, introducing myself that way. It just seems like an internet thing to me because I haven't met anyone irl like this.

Please, comrades, help me murder the occupying force in my mind. Give me some reading to do or something. Unlimited genocide on heteronormativity.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago (1 children)

I struggle with very similar feelings to your own. My core insight thus far has been that 'it's a childish thing' is a projection/pre-emption of our belief that we will not be taken seriously or respected when we share our authentic selves. You have a very real and profound experience of dysphoria and non-cis gender. It's not a question of whether or not that is true. It's a question of whether it feels acceptable to name it and own it. Currently, the most visible people owning trans genders are young and highly online because 1) (duh!) you need to be highly online to be visible online, and 2) we live in a society that fetishizes youth.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago) (1 children)

it's a childish thing' is a projection/pre-emption of our belief that we will not be taken seriously or respected when we share our authentic selves

This is it deeper-sadness

You have a very real and profound experience of dysphoria and non-cis gender. It's not a question of whether or not that is true. It's a question of whether it feels acceptable to name it and own it.

Thank you meow-hug

we live in a society that fetishizes youth.

You know, this has been a surprising difficult thing to deal with for me. A lot of dysphoria for me comes from aging. I've been wearing women's clothing for years, but I have this idea in my head that I'm going to have to stop one day when I'm "too old". Actually, there's less of a feeling of "you look too masculine" and more of a feeling of "you're too old to be playing around with this crap".

[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago (1 children)

Well the hard and good news is, you are not going to grow out of it! You are never going to have a fully realized girlhood in a way you may want on some level, but that does not mean that fully realized and joyous femininity is foreclosed to you. One of my friends was 'I'm going to wear women's jeans and do garish eye shadow and that's enough/all I can do' for years before being ready/able to commit to transition in her middle thirties. That wasn't 'arrested development' or failure. That was the level of self-expression that she was ready and able to live in safely. It's never too late and you're never ready until you're ready. trans-heart

The way I am working to think about it that I have to have grace for what feels possible right now as I prepare the emotional/ideological groundwork for more public transition in the future. As opposed to flaggelating myself for not 'transing hard enough'. Ultimately, that's another form of punishment-deflection by guilt. That leads nowhere but pain.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago

Thank you for your kindness, comrade. I needed to hear it.

I'm sending you good vibes as you prepare the groundwork for your public transition bridget-pride