post
honestly everyone responsible should be fucking shot as a traitor and dumped in the nearest forest for the carrion. if we won't even protect our own from our own what's the fucking point
Its wild that an org as big and structured as PSL still has structural issues that boil down to a lot of the shit from The Tyranny of Structurelessness. (The parts of elite formation and such especially.)
Feels like it'd have to have been intentional at this point, but maybe not. Regardless its a very bad look, disgusting behavior from these men and everyone complicit in the coverup. Sorry, you have to do the hard thing, remove the abusers from positions of power, take the PR hit, but gain in trust overall.
Having someone who signed onto the public statements on the last major PSL scandal now coming out with her own allegations is just above and beyond. Ialready had no huge love or trust for my local chapter but this puts it down in the dumps with national DSA
Thanks for sharing this. Very curious what PSL members here think and feel about this and other allegations that have come out in the last year or so.
I had to step down last year from leadership because of a situation like this where I was extremely vulnerable, and I was asked not to discuss it with anyone. I was effectively cauterized as a threat to the party's image instead of listened to, empathized with, and brought back into the fold with understanding and respect. The issues I faced came from a leader who then went on to fail and fail and fail, but faced no penalties. I felt ashamed and I felt scared, and I begged for the person who had betrayed my trust to face some kind of consequence, but she didn't, and at great harm to the local branch.
It feels almost cathartic to see I wasn't the only one, but also numb. I wanted to build the party we need. I helped to build our local branch from almost nothing. And when it was time for me to have the support I needed, I was hung out to dry.
I don't know what the future looks like for the local branch, or for the PSL at large and the ML movement in the US; but I can only hope this is a stepping stone and a learning moment that the communist left will learn from, take seriously, and adapt to. That probably means forming a new pre-party cadre network? For better or for worse the PSL has generated and trained many wonderful cadre like myself, and we all deserve a political home with the correct political program but without this continued and genuinely systemic nonsense. Also, I worked with Chris, his shit tracks.
Whatever the fuck, I'm so disappointed, I only wish my case was a unique one. Maybe by even sharing all this I'm practically doxxing myself more than I already have, but just, DemCent can't mean keeping shit like this going.
Chris made a big fucking show about his military style discipline when I worked with him, just for him to be implicated in TWO scandals in this very article????? Not to mention, like, knowing about this and not doing shit
Chris made a big fucking show about his military style discipline when I worked with him
My branch had someone like this too, and there have similarly been rumors of harmful behaviors floating around him. it's a type of posture i feel a lot of the org's rhetoric feeds into that can become an easy cudgel for people in the party with harmful tendencies and also against dissent and against questioning of the Party.
And also, deeply sorry that happened to you comrade
you deserve better than that and the fact that this is such an ingrained pattern in an org I really believed in makes me feel sick
Thank you, comrade. I hadn't read the description, so... I didn't realize you were a party member as well. I also didn't want to post, or say, or do anything because of not wanting to harm the larger organization. Even in my personal life, I refrained from telling anybody what I went through for like a month. Even my closest friends, because I was told not to and I was so, I don't know, terrified of just fucking up, you know?
I keep refreshing this page to like, I don't know... commiserate with someone? I just hate that I'm like one of those people now, one of the people I was terrified of when I was on local branch leadership talking openly about this stuff because like I think everybody in the party deserves to have the party that is what we all dream of. Like dude, there are so many fucking awesome, awesome, awesome, awesome people that I've worked with, and I'm just so pissed that this comes from National every single fucking time.
I thought this was the one place where National and Locals worked hand in hand because that's exactly what we need in this fucking evil empire. Yet these people fucked it up! These people fucked it up so much and I lost months of my life being completely apoplectic about what I went through.
I just still feel like numb, but pissed. I'm so pissed. I'm just so frustrated that I wasn't the only one. I'm so frustrated that it wasn't just the person I was talking with from national that I begged for help from. I kept telling myself first that it wasn't that big of a deal and then that, you know, it was the tough call to make, but he made the right call. And then I told myself it was just him, you know, and not like a bigger overall issue. But it turns out it goes all the way up to the fucking Central Committee. The fucking Central Committee. Are you fucking kidding me? Are these guys like 12? I thought they built the fucking party that was like historically needed in this fucking moment. It turns out it really is just another place to get abused.
Which fucking pisses me off. I got so much flack from like the anarchist left here where I'm at, which is still pretty significant even with their shocking and horrifying history of sexual abuse scandals that I myself was also subject to. The way I saw it, I would be protected because what kind of communist organization would be so short-sighted to not protect victims? But it turns out, a organization I completely stuck my neck out for, an organization that I helped fucking build locally, just, it just, it just is the same thing. Democratic centralism literally is the tool for liberation, right?
One amongst many, but a pretty important one. And yet, and yet, I always hear how in October 7th, the party started planning and was ready to be in the streets on October 8th while the rest of the left was still paralyzed. That's like the power of democratic centralism. But what the fuck is this shit? This isn't democratic centralism. Hell, in my local fucking branch, our structure of organization has just completely, like, frozen so many valuable, hardworking people. I always have to hear about October 8th whenever there's issues with democratic centralism or our decision-making structure in the party.
I can't say it enough. I nearly lost my job because I was so disabled by my experience. Honestly, the worst part wasn't even what I went through initially, but just the fact that it was covered up and I was forced to trickle-truth so much about it with the people that I loved in my life and trusted comrades, and still, the vast majority don't even know what I went through. I read books about, like, understanding betrayal trauma and shit. I started out feeling numb, but the more I write, the more emotional I get. It feels like a fucking release. I honestly don't blame anyone who's put so much into the party. I did too. But it just sucks. That's all I can say. It just really fucking sucks. I thought we were building the future, and I was wrong.
I'm sorry about your experiences well, comrade. It just hurts so much that we're not alone.

This is not going by without issue or response internally. It highlights many long term problems with the Becker leadership clique that have been held up as criticisms by many party members for years. It was also a massive violation of trust within the party - Eugene was the face of the party and its political leadership much more than the Beckers for years, and he essentially just poofed away with a shallow lie about why. That meant the membership was broadly deceived about the real situation and went on to vote for him to the Central Committee again, which surely would not have happened if this was known.
The party is long overdue for a major clearing out of the Central Committee and comrades are working hard towards that end. The organization is extremely strong and extremely effective at producing communist cadre - it would not be difficult to raise up a new group of leaders more suited to the task and replace the old boys club (which has lots of women in this case).
This was already a year of major internal changes to improve democratization and reduce centralization in the party because of issues like this, but they now need to rise to the highest levels of the org. I'm optimistic we'll clear out where we need to and come out a more capable revolutionary vanguard, cause sure as shit no one else is up for it.
as a former member who left over something far less severe (the deeply suspect way leadership handled the split a few months back, plus a creeping feeling that rank and file - including myself - were just seen as employees to be exploited by a bunch of shitty bosses), I think PSL is very much a not-actually-democratic centralist org where dissent - even in supposedly dedicated spaces for it - is seen as a threat and is squashed and where leadership expects blind deference and obedience.
this is the exact kind of environment that breeds horrific coverups like this one and which suffocates accountability for harmful behavior and makes it impossible to protect and genuinely care for victims. like i said in my post, this type of harm is obviously a society-wide issue under patriarchy that doesn't have an easy quick fix, but removing this ossified, corrupt leadership clique would be a necessary precondition in the specific context of PSL.
Building organizations is usually easier than fixing them if the things that need fixing are deep power structures and there's no impetus from within them to overhaul. You could spend your entire life trying to reform an organization "from within" and fail simply because those structures would rather maintain themselves than do anything else. The methods and reformability of an organization are what actually happens, not what they say they are. For example, from members of a different org, I learned they would get routinely harassed as individuals for all of their personal decisions and social media posts, by leadership, based on sweeping false declarations by leadership about how Maoist political criticism works and is beneficial. Rather than reform, that org kept all of its same leadership and bad practices because everyone who recognized the issue left rather than spend their time trying to organize against the leading and founding clique in their organization. Time that was already taking up more headspace, energy, and discussion time than actually doing any org programming. Org programming that was itself not particularly deliberated, let alone criticized, as it was introduced by that head clique and criticizing it meant facing personal rebuke in public.
The only thing that isn't easier when building organizations is actually doing it very well, as it means accounting for a thousand different things. This is why the best builders were already members of orgs that were most of the way there but needed changes. The practices are ingrained and can be reproduced with good modifications.
This cover-up didn't serve to protect the PSL it only served to protect a perpetrator of sexual violence within the PSL.
“Communists must be ready at all times to stand up for the truth, because truth is in the interests of the people; Communists must be ready at all times to correct their mistakes, because mistakes are against the interests of the people.” (Chairman Mao, On Coalition Government)
Just want to share a tid bit about Brian Becker. My first introduction to him was on Sputnik Radio's Loud and Clear podcast, where he co-hosted with John Kiraikou... The former CIA officer, who in 2007 seems to have just blurted out in an interview that the CIA was waterboarding people during the Bush administration... He left the CIA in 2004, and I'm pretty sure it wasn't because of the torture. Gina Haspel was directing the program at the time, and so she was implicated, she was later Appointed deputy director under Trump 1, and director under Biden. Kiraikou served 2 years in prison for that interview. The thing is, in the podcast he always portrayed himself a having been a whistle blower, and that he was trying to take down Haspel like he was some kind of hero. I'm not clear on the details of the case though.
At any rate, he gets this co-host gig with Brian Becker on a explicitly socialist podcast produced under the umbrella of "Russian State Media" Sputnik Radio. Brian Becker is an old head activist, I've heard him many times talk about protests he participated in back in the 80s or so.
Both of them offered pretty principled takes as far as I could tell at the time, but it's been years since they cancelled the show and parted ways.
But what the fuck is a founder of a revolutionary ML party doing, chumming it up with an "former" CIA officer? It's weird imo.
While I'm in no way saying that the PSL has any particular claim to being "the real communists", it feels a bit weird to immediately try and retroactively discredit them as leftists in the wake of this. Yes, real leftist orgs can absolutely have predators hiding among their ranks, just like any other organization can, and instead of implying that this sort of thing could never happen to us true leftists, we should remain alert to this possibility.
I don't think we need to reach for "CIA assets" as an explanation for PSL's limitations. Its far more simply explained by: "demcent organization has ossified leadership clique". Tale as old as american communism.
We know these people insinuate themsves into any organization of any sort. So its no surprise. The question for a political organization is how they treat it.
The link in the post is hardly at all about the initial assault. Its mostly about the subsequent manipulations. The betrayal of the physical act by 1 person vs the betrayal of the organizational act by several people. Its in the context of what came before and after.
In PSL, which is known for insisting members not air disagreements in public, what is the process for this stuff? Knowing as we do that it will certainly occur.
And that agents of the state use SA and IPV to diminish women. Class treachery one way or the other.
"but he does so much! What would we do without him?"
How to decide
- How to save him?
- Is he worth it?
Not every guy who "does a lot" is worth the drama and pain he charges as a fee.
Eventually, I was asked to move to New York City to help plan the 2019 Congress. Once there, I spent every day with Ben and his family. We organized out of his apartment. We cooked and I helped care for his young child. In those years, I was one of only two party staffers.
Well that is weird.
He told me that the only people he had told were [Ben's brother] Brian, Ben’s father, and Karina, Ben’s wife.
Still reading through the blog, and this stood out. I don't think it's healthy at all to have some family be the head of the org. Why is Ben's father and wife privy to private party matters?
Also, what is up with PSL NYC being as shitty as DSA NYC apparently? Did the feds saw that the NYC branch of the BPP was the best branch and decided to run a COIN operation to make sure that every NYC branch of subsequent socialist orgs would be the shittiest branch?
NYC was deliberately chosen as the center for organizing the party, like the party capital. It's less of a center among many and more like central, its actions tend to reflect national direction.
Not another one. Between this and DSA's endorsement of Platner, it has not been great for the US left recently.
EDIT: As someone in the belly of the beast, what the hell am I supposed to do? Leave and join some other tiny, splitter faction? Go back to DSA? This sucks.
I regret to inform you that there's a movement within DSA to endorse AOC for president.
Baumann affair all over again...
Extremely disappointing to see, and the test of the party will be its ability to handle such a situation effectively. SA is unacceptable.
(imma be honest, i think leftist parties should put harsh cutoff point on age of around 25 to save everyone, people both know their worth (and less likely to take this stuff), and it should reduce young radical->finds a stable job thingy, and thus ruthlessly is squeezed for juices in the heavy rotation of young ones, because party knows it's statistically likely to happen, while older core ossifies/becomes unaccountable)
Age limit the primary party and run a separate youth wing like CPB does with YCL.
Oddly enough I've never heard an accusation like this in any British orgs. Either the british orgs are better at coverups (doubtful?), it's a uniquely american thing and more frequent there because of it (also doubtful?) or it's used in ops by US intelligence frequently while not used in ops by UK intelligence, which would explain the huge disparity in accusations/cases.
I do find it fairly odd that this comes up so frequently in american communist orgs. Maybe i just grossly underestimate how much more gross american men are.
It's not that the org in any broad sense tried to cover it up - it's that there was a tiny group of maybe 5 people at the very top who knew and hid it from everybody, even most of the Central Committee.
"The purpose of a thing is what it does" applies to organizational actions as well. While the specifics you say are true, if it's not the organization then this long-term leadership clique will be removed via organizational revolt in short order. If not, one must accept that actually it is the organization that is doing it.
I've experienced this on a more local level with the same kind of response to our own Baumann affair from a member of the NOD assigned to my branch. The same tendencies persist outside of this specific circumstances
it's the Becker leadership clique who hold outsized undemocratic power in the organization. yes, a more accurate headline would have been "and leadership tried to cover it up" but I was hastily posting something deeply upsetting but also deeply important to spread awareness of in socialist spaces.
for as long as this cabal of corrupt, opportunistic perverts holds the amount of power they do - and until PSL takes seriously building actual structures of internal democracy and accountability around harm - this is the nature of the org, sadly. that's why my first prescription for fixing it is ousting these people; a necessary though not sufficient precondition.
this isn't just me shouting from the sidelines of the shitposting mines, either. i quit PSL a few months ago after 2.5 years as a member over something much less severe (but still fucking shitty!) that showed these fundamental failings and contradictions, and some of my dearest friends are still in the Party. its rank-and-file as well as the broader working class deserve better from the orgs that are supposed to be fighting for them and with them.
accuses Puryear of the assault and Ben Becker of covering it up.
top 50 comments