
post
I’m just wondering why that kid’s watching a guy drop a deuce
Much worse, it looks like he's watching 1 guy 1 cup... 🫥
Do...do you really want the context?
I was one of the unlucky 10,000 the last time this was posted. Let someone else have their day ruined.
Wait is that actually supposed to be 1 guy 1 jar
I have aphantasia.
How does reading and watching it in your mind's eye change anything from just watching it on a screen?
I prefer audio books because it allows me to critically think better during because I can listen and think at same time, but reading words takes more brain power.
I guess it's a matter of preference, because in my mind there's no way listening takes less brainpower than reading.
That's probably very different from person to person, since its different how well they can parse heard words and seen words. For me hearing is way faster, but I’m also more likely to confuse sounds than characters.
I don't think this is very related to phantasia.. With a book you can stop and think about things (imaginatively or critically). With video your entire attention is captured and it's quite difficult to step away from the narrative being presented. In my experience audio is somewhere in between, and I'm able to zone out on my own tangent sometimes (but this is annoying, because I miss things)
We usually think in linguistic concepts even when reading a book, one of the most difficult things to do with a student when they are learning drawing is teaching them to really see instead of thinking of linguistic traits. I have aphantasia and it is difficult for me to recall visual traits so instead i focus on visual recipes, or construction while drawing. It is difficult for me to recall faces for example but if i reduce a face to geometric shapes and proportions and do a lot of trial and error so i can approximate a face I've seen.
So when reading is not that I am seeing things, but i am making a conceptual map, an abstraction. Kinda like how dreams are like stories we tell ourselves to the point they might seem like intangible images. Sometimes I feel my brain relate stuff i read to things i've already seen, or builds some conceptual bridge between known concepts to unknown ones.
But reading is also a practice on itself different than hearing. Language has aesthetics, rhythm character. I feel i learn more about the aesthetic beauty of language by reading it on the page than hearing it on an audio book because it forces me to build that bridge between my horizon of understanding and the authors'.
This is especially true for authors that have an entirely different background than me because to understand them i need to read slower and research. Something that audio books doesn't allow with it's predisposed presentation.
aphantasia - the inability to voluntarily create mental images in your mind's eye.
I guess this extends to reading? I wasn’t sure if that would count as “voluntarily” since it just seems to happen for me.
I read to my kids every night and if there is a movie of the book we’re reading, I will finish the book with them before we watch the movie. In this way, the images they have in their minds as we read are theirs. Sometimes interesting things happen in your mind when it needs to create its own images and I think this is a personal part of reading that makes it more than just consumption but also a creative act unto itself.
Once Hollywood has made Jennifer Lawrence the protagonist, that’s all you’ll be able to see ever again.
However none of this would apply in your case so read or watch or listen however works best for you. Personally I find audiobooks a terrible way to read. My mind wanders instead of focusing more on the text. I realize I’ve been thinking about someone else for several minutes, and ultimately don’t retain as much from the book in the end. It’s like “having the tv on in the background” while doing household chores. That’s fine for stuff I don’t really care about, if I just want to relax and divert my mind. But if I really want to enjoy the book and get everything I can from it, I need to read it.
Brains are obviously different. You can listen and think at the same time. I can read aloud to my kids while thinking of what I need to do at work tomorrow. However if someone is talking to me there is no way I can think about anything except the words coming out of their mouth. This is so much the case that if a person talks haltingly or takes a long time coming to the point, it physically hurts me because my brain is locked on them but they aren’t using it efficiently.
This is the 3rd time this has been posted this year and the comments section is still clueless even with a caption hint
What did I miss? The guy pooping? And this is just boomer humor. Books are great but visual art can do the same thing for my brain.
It's not poop. And it's not leaving his pooper.
Oh God. Is it... Is it going in? And do I want to know what "it" is?
It's going in. And it's a simple, plain, glass jar.
No, it's something much worse. Just move on.
My curiosity will get the better of me one way or another.
Tap for just the name of the reference
It's a reference to the Shock Site video "1 man 1 jar"
don't tap this or I'll tell you what that is.
A man sits on a glass jar, and it shatters in his anus. He whimpers but does not speak, and removes pieces of bloody glass from his anus with his shaking hands.
I warned you.
Fuck man. I think I've heard of this but def haven't watched it. Thanks all the same.
And this is just boomer humor.
you doubt me? I'm so offended :<
Is that jar guy?
this is a nuanced topic. as much as this meme is trying to be intelligent, it's just as dumb as what it's critiquing.
you learn to think from books, but film and TV exercises that thinking. in film you'll find symbolism and metaphor and meaning, intentional or not.
being able to extract that is intelligence, not raw facts. americans love to boast about how educated they are and about the virtues of education, but why are there millions of users of goodreads and letterboxd and few can write a coherent paragraph about a book they read or a film they watched?
it's because of this type of braindead thinking--it's all about imagination!!! imagination is great, but it's really about thinking; it's about not being stuck in thought patterns that lead nowhere.
Yes the symbolism in One Man, One Jar cannot be denied.
1 man 1 jar 😍
What's that? A shadow with two legs and a poop falling inbetween? I really don't get it.
i think it's one guy one jar
You can access to fantasy and fairytale story through both online and book, depend on your choice
when i first saw this meme i thought the left one was a dark fountain from deltarune lol
I mean they do represent fiction
Like I understand the sentiment but I've got ADHD so the sentiment is bullshit for me.
I have ADHD so when I get into reading I read a lot, but I haven't been able to focus on reading anything in like 4 years.
I read a lot of SciFi when I was a teen. I learned not to bother seeing the movie if one was made. They always got so much wrong, and by "wrong" I mean it didn't match my imagination.
This is why I'm currently hesitating to watch Hail Mary Project.
top 50 comments