Robot Chicken taught me that everyone is a Cylon!
I assume that is referencing this clip (from 1:10)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FzH6GVBSXSk
And this clip (from 2:10)
So, how do they do in case of birth or surgery? Are doctors and surgeon a caste 'in the know'?
Humanoid Cylons are physiologically indistinguishable from humans. Remember how much time/effort was put into developing the "Cylon detector" blood test, and how they ended up determining that the technology wasn't effective and that it was impossible to tell them apart? I take it that a surgeon could operate on a humanoid Cylon without knowing it was not human at all.
Baltar's Cylon detector did actually work through, so there is some difference.
Did it though?
Or was he bullshitting the whole time? Did it catch Colonel Tigh or Chief Tyrol? (Any of the cylons discovered toward the end of the series).
Out of all the dozen or so individuals who were confirmed to be Cylons by the end of the series, the only individual who was detected by the Cylon detector was Boomer. That is a pretty awful accuracy rate, and could possibly have just mistakenly flagged the wrong sample as a Cylon. It may have been a total fluke that the one sample that it detected was someone who did turn out to actually be a Cylon.
It did get abandoned early in the series if I recall (been a while) and from what I recall he did tweak the results after Boomer so that more or less only he could tell so maybe it did work, the first "results" before her were totally fudged so who even knows. I had also forgotten that
Tap for spoiler
Ellen was tested on screen as well, we just never know what the actual results were. I need to to do a rewatch but I honestly I wouldn't have been surprised if it did work for the final five and he just kept that to himself.
Wait, if that's the case then why does anybody even care?
That's the fundamental flaw in the show.
If there's no difference, then who the fuck cares.
Also, you can program deep sleeper agents to activate and sabotage the ships
But also cylons aren't bad guys, they can help the humans.
Also, cylons have super powers and can break solid steel.
Also, cylons are immortal and can resurrect.
Also, there's absolutely no hardware for any of this.
The whole show makes no sense if you look at it too close.
The whole show makes no sense if you look at it too close.
100%. Just like the show "Lost", they didn't really know what the end was going to be when they started the show. Admittedly, Lost was much worse, often the writers had no idea what would happen 3 episodes ahead. I think on Galactic they at least had season outlines (but no idea what would happen in the next season).

Narrator: They did not have a plan.
I like the overall thing, but, how do you explain the loss of cultural memory?
I guess at some point, the false humans could/would program their "global" firmwares to forget, but, at that point they are completely at the mercy of the technology's ability to self-perpetuate; if it develops problems, they will not even know that it exists (so presumably nanotech) and therefore not know how to fix.
One could posit some group of hidden technologists of indeterminate size, who maintain the systems. Perhaps they are even AI nanomachines that walk around with the very sophisticated automatons.
Biggest question/doubt on my part is, why the hell would any being so advanced as to build a Cylon, ever want to be human?
To keep their humanity?
Interesting. I wonder if we could fit the angels into this. Perhaps they are from a more advanced iteration? As in, maybe the conflict we are following is between the first and second set of cylons. Perhaps there are third or father sets too. Maybe they send out some emissaries to aid the other iterations. A bit like the istari in lotr
Running with this idea and the mythology of the Thirteenth Tribe. Perhaps it does, or did exist after a split or exodus in the time of the first and second sets of cylons. What we're presented is a bottled (at a universal scale) experiment of the remaining 'angels'. The last of the early cylons working from the long dead memories of humanity, still driven by an extermination directive long forgotten by 'modern' cylon iterations.
Science Fiction
Welcome to /c/ScienceFiction
December book club canceled. Short stories instead!
We are a community for discussing all things Science Fiction. We want this to be a place for members to discuss and share everything they love about Science Fiction, whether that be books, movies, TV shows and more. Please feel free to take part and help our community grow.
- Be civil: disagreements happen, but that doesn’t provide the right to personally insult others.
- Posts or comments that are homophobic, transphobic, racist, sexist, ableist, or advocating violence will be removed.
- Spam, self promotion, trolling, and bots are not allowed
- Put (Spoilers) in the title of your post if you anticipate spoilers.
- Please use spoiler tags whenever commenting a spoiler in a non-spoiler thread.