That is one theory of how teleportation will work. Otherwise, you have a replication machine.
post
Shades of The Prestige?
In fairness to Mr Tesla, his machine didn't kill. It made a perfect living duplicate. (The magician on the other hand...)
bro could have stopped at one copy and taken turns bowing like his nemisis did, but chose to die instead
Never bought into the whole, "sleep is the same thing," argument. There's no period during which your brain functions cease during sleep. They slow during non-REM sleep, then reach near waking levels once you enter REM, but they never end. That's not remotely like having your entire body disassembled at molecular level and rebuilt somewhere else. One is essentially like a computer that's screen has gone idle while it performs background tasks. The other is like transferring all of your files to a new computer and then throwing the original into a woodchipper.
Conciousness, what makes you, you, is not your brain functions. A "braindead" person usually still has a functioning part of the brain that regulates heartbeat. But the parts that are required for conciousness are gone.
The point behind the sleep analogy isn't that everything shuts down as in death, but your conciousness shuts down. It's more like a computer that has suspended it's processes to disk (aka hibernated) but then went into low-power mode instead of powering off completely. You can wake it back up and it restart these processes. You could even buy a new computer identical to the old one, copy the hard drive over bit by bit and have the new computer launch all the old processes. Are they then the same processes or different ones? A calculation that was suspended will pick up where it left of after all.
Conciousness, what makes you, you, is not your brain functions.
This is an extremely debatable assertion that scientists and philosophers will still be debating long after you and I are dead, but empirically, the evidence is pointing towards, "No, your consciousness is just a byproduct of that lump of meat in your skull." Phineas Gage, for example, discovered that a huge portion of what made him, him was actually his left-frontal lobe.
We could argue about conciousness, the soul, and the ship of theses for hours, and it would all still be opinion, but what is not opinion is this; your consciousness is being run on meat hardware, physical damage to or a chemical imbalance in that hardware will effect your consciousness, and it is constantly running processes, even when in sleep mode, until it is permanently shutdown. Based on that information, I would not let anyone disintegrate my brain, even if fhey reassembled it perfectly.
This should be its own post tbh, so I can upvote it again.
Edit: Also, source?
oh sorry I though it had a watermark https://www.existentialcomics.com/comic/1
Star Trek transporters.
Time to post the first Existential Comics again
my personal opinion is that instant (i.e. arbitrarily close to speed of light) teleportation machines could be built in theory, but doing so is really expensive and there's just no economical reason to do so.
for example, for fast travel, we already have aircraft and rockets. Yet nobody would use them to ship objects produced in china to europe, e.g. cars, if there's no time-critical component (i.e. food that spoils very quickly etc.). So the fastest way of travel is typically also the most expensive one, while cheaper modes of transport take more time.
Then, you can think of a teleportation device as a mode of transport where the speed approaches the speed of light. If our previous experience is anything to go by, that means that the cost of transport would increase enormously, and thus practically nobody would use it anyways. So that's the practical side to this thing.
Explicitly don't work like that, the Transporter Problem Thought Experiment was "what if they worked like that"
But in Star Trek it's a streaming connection, kept in the Transporter Buffer
Ok, then explain Thomas Riker
Reminds me of the one-minute time machine
$me = "π§";
$stillMe = & $me;
unset($me);
print($stillMe); // wohoo, teleportation rocks!!!
$me = "π§";
$copyOfMe = $me;
unset($me); // π this sucks!!!
print($copyOfMe); // wait, what happened?
the reference never changed position in memory, so nothing actually happened during the teleportation process other than a re-labelling.
For real teleportation, that memory has to physically change position. I would do it gradually though, bit-by-bit, synchronized, and very fast.
The idea is that if you slow it down, you witness half-yourself getting destroyed exactly as you witness your other half getting created, with the only carry-over being a single 1 or a 0
So teleportation is like going into the woodchipper feet first? Ok, now I slowly understand McCoys problems with that invention.

Arent we kinda new every micromoment? I mean, the electrons powering our feelings and deeds are new every moment in time. The atoms we are made of are exchanged over time so we arent even the same matter after x many years... So we are never who we were before. Dying seems to be a part of living, not just the end...
Edit: even the Information saved in our bain change over time, they get more. And remembering things isnt correct every time so even the quality of information changes...
Whew. So that wasn't me on video last night. π
Yes. I think this thought experiment ultimately boils down to "do you believe in a soul".
what is this prestige that everyone keeps talking about?
The Prestige is a movie where Wolverine and Batman fight in a battle of who is the best magician. David Bowie makes a teleportation machine for Logan to teleport across the entire theater to the shock of the audience.
Tap for spoiler
But we learn that the machine is not a teleporter, but a distance copier--the original Logan still remains on the pad while his copy stands across the expanse, beaming triumphantly down on the amazed audience. Logan rigs a trap door for his original self to fall through and drown every night, and every night, he never knows if he will be the one to die or the one to live.
Reading this was better than the actual movie.
But the movie also has Alfred!
And Black Widow.
Unreadable quality
That's a problem with infosec.pub instance, not with the post.
Atomic teleportation where a pattern or parts are converted or reassembled = death
Quantum teleportation where particles exist in multiple locations states before collapsing into one⦠not so sure.
My theory is that the being who created the totems is borrowing the power of each soul's death and using that to recreate their body on the other side. There must be some minor difference in power that this being collects for itself. Even a small difference would be worth it at scale.

![[Repost of the comic from OP]](https://thelemmy.club/api/v3/image_proxy?url=https%3A%2F%2Flemmy.world%2Fpictrs%2Fimage%2F3da386f9-dfba-4bee-96a0-093e0e790386.jpeg)
top 50 comments