I'm convinced that the people complaining of Star Trek being woke are bots and Heritage Foundation trolls.
Me and my partner hate discovery, and its not because its woke, that half the reason ST is good, but because its crewed argumentative children who are too busy going to discos to tackle the real business of star fleet.
Embarrassing writting and its doesn't respect its viewers at all.
Lots of the new trek is really not woke enough! We are in a utopia, what is all that dystopian shit doing in the stories?!
Yeah, and they skipped forwards a 1000 years basically to some post-utopian-post-apocalyptic universe with "the burn".
And it's kinda weird for me that everything pretty much changed less in that 1000 years than it did in the few centuries from our time to the 24th century. And that people like Tilly have no problems going about and even being professors.
Give back space-utopia with story's about plane regular starship missions intercut with some very basic personal life storyline and then have something go wrong with the regular. mission and have that intertwine with the b-storyline about the personal thing at the end and eveyone learns something and is nice to each other.
SNW is soooooo superior to Discovery and Academy. Although I do like that the Doc's back and it's not as bad as Discovery, but...
Yeah Star Trek is being written by idiots that don't understand how to write Star Trek. The message used to be that the social issues we have today would be alien to a future utopian society. It was the aliens had all of these social issues, but the protagonaists have moved past those issues and have to be reminded that humans had these problems in the past. It says we should stop being weird about shit so we can have cool starships.
Now it seems the future utopian society later decides they want to go back to being racist assholes again. I think the writers may have good intentions, but carelessly made a very depressing statement about how these problems will always come back and can never be overcome permanently.
I think the difference between most of the older trek and the newer stuff is that while they did obvious stuff like this, the most impactful social stuff they did was treat revolutionary change as boring.
TOS had a black woman bridge officer, and they didn't make a big deal about it, because in the future there was nothing remarkable about it.
This is a really good point but I feel there is a double edged sword here. Loads of old school bigoted nerds love star trek because for whatever reason they actually don't pick up on the compassionate, far left messaging.
It was also different when 50 years ago, a black woman as bridge officer was scandal to right wing sensationalist media.
The overt and sometimes performative progressive details that are present now push the boundaries in a similar manner to the old boring change, while being much more noticeable to the rest of the audience.
And when they did confront the issues, those issues were alien things, the federation was past all this nonsense and as you say, boring mundane stuff and the alien issues were always "oh we got over that hundreds of years ago, we learned about that in history".
People who criticize new (or old) Trek for its wokeness are overwhelmingly not on this platform. People here who dislike Kurtzman-era Trek take issue with the lacklustre writing. At least, that's my impression. I suppose it's possible that there are a bunch of bigots commenting that I've blocked and/or have defederated with.
Absent that, the proliferation of these sorts of memes just strikes me as pandering, coupled with a misguided, combative defensiveness of anything that falls under the corporate-owned Trek umbrella, regardless of quality.
I am not an anti-woke person in the slightest, and I wouldn’t say Star Trek was ever subtle about its leftist ideals.
But it did use to present us with a more optimistic view of the future of humanity that was largely beyond the petty dramas we have today, while still leaving room for the fact that no matter how much you’ve progressed, you do always have to fight to keep the ideals and society you’ve built. Allegories for modern problems were largely relegated to interactions with humanlike alien species so that the theme of humanity itself being “better than it was” is left intact.
And it did lose a little something when the Alex Kurtzman era came along and took the federation and humanity back to the stupid ages in order to get the point across.
The scene in Picard where you have a character living in what looks like poverty despite it being a post-scarcity age, and trying to draw parallels between her and Picard, and the different classes we have today, because she lived in a trailer and he owned a vineyard, was just next-level misunderstanding the source material. Hello they don’t have capitalism, there’s no money. It was long established by this point that humans excel due to their drive to achieve, not command a salary.
It does feel like Star Trek used to be woke, but was a story from the mouths of people who had something to say, to now it’s woke, but in a very icky corporate-sterilized kinda way.
It does feel like Star Trek used to be woke, but was a story from the mouths of people who had something to say, to now it’s woke, but in a very icky corporate-sterilized kinda way.
I doubt its going to get better, considering what its parent company has become.
God that scene in Picard made me immediately stop watching the whole series. There is just no coming back from that.
The same happend for me with the opening scenes from Starfleet Academy. How the heck can you portray a utopia with an introduction that is less humane than what we have now in developed countries?!
Yeah that Picard scene alone de-canonizes the entire show. Like you can’t just casually retcon exploitative capitalism back into hundreds of years of established lore lol.
leaving room for the fact that no matter how much you’ve progressed, you do always have to fight to keep the ideals and society you’ve built
"Vigilance, Mr. Worf."
It does feel like Star Trek used to be woke, but was a story from the mouths of people who had something to say, to now it’s woke, but in a very icky corporate-sterilized kinda way.
Exactly it, modern Trek's wokeness is diluted and committeed to death, it's the writing equivalent of performative rainbow capitalism from corporations that now toady to the Trump administration.
Yep. Good analysis. Probably why I haven’t been able to get along with much of the Kurtzman era Trek. I’ve started Strange New Worlds and Lower Decks and find those two to be actually watchable, but Discovery and Picard I noped out of pretty hard after around a season each, and have no desire to even start Academy.
I will die on the hill that Lower Decks is not only the only nu-trek that is actual Star Trek, but that it actually belongs up there with the actual legacy Trek shows it parodies. And it’s got plenty of gay woke stuff in it. But despite being a parody, and forgiving the very rough first season (It’s ST, hello), it’s obviously that the writers actually understand what Star Trek is.
I fear a lot of people will write it off as “Star Trek does Rick & Morty” and it’s a shame. It has a TAMARIAN bridge officer for gods sake.
And it’s got plenty of gay woke stuff in it
I would like to stress that they're treating all the gay woke stuff as entirely normal and common, just like original trek.
On the other hand, Discovery had a painfully long and exceedingly meaningless arc about a character's struggles with society's views on their gender... When said society doesn't have any negative views at all.
It felt like me gathering my family together to have a deeply emotional announcement that I always put on my left sock first.
Damn it! You've got me in tears!
Discovery had a painfully long and exceedingly meaningless arc about a character’s struggles with society’s views on their gender… When said society doesn’t have any negative views at all.
Who’s character arc are you talking about here? I don’t think that describes anything that happened in the show.
I know Adira was an incredibly forgettable character in probably the worst Discovery season, but Adira's "I'm actually gender neutral" coming-out talk with Stamets half a season after they were introduced was incredibly mismatched with everything Trek.
Especially with the absolutely amazing way DS9 handled the Curzon/Jadzia thing.
Edit: to see an actually good way to handle a transition on screen, watch The Umbrella Academy.
Especially with the absolutely amazing way DS9 handled the Curzon/Jadzia thing.
The way DS9 did the "of course they're here and it's no big deal because it's the enlightened utopian future" inclusion with a character who was effectively trans was in the finest tradition of Trek, dating back to the first pilot of TOS. And you can tell there's a "but" coming up because of the otherwise well-deserved praise that we're heaping on here.
But "Facets."
The episode that was based on the Sybil TV movie. The episode that made joined Trill explicitly plural. And they made a beeline for the long hackneyed "evil alter" trope that the plural community has been unfairly saddled with since 1886. As well as the "slutty alter" trope, but it was already pretty well established by that point that Curzon was a horndog.
The way DS9 did the “of course they’re here and it’s no big deal because it’s the enlightened utopian future” inclusion with a character who was effectively trans was in the finest tradition of Trek, dating back to the first pilot of TOS.
Not just that, but Jadzia was an actual character who had a personality and contributed to the show. Same for Chekhov, or Uhura, or dozens of others who were fully realized characters first and foremost.
Adira was just there, and nothing else. It felt like the entire character was just there to tick a diversity box, and nothing else.
But “Facets.”
Yeaaaaaahhhh...
Not just that, but Jadzia was an actual character who had a personality and contributed to the show. Same for Chekhov, or Uhura, or dozens of others who were fully realized characters first and foremost.
Adira was just there, and nothing else. It felt like the entire character was just there to tick a diversity box, and nothing else.
We agree entirely. It kinda felt like the writers on Disco eventually started treating main engineering like an skee-ball machine. It's where they put the tokens.
I always put on my left sock first
You monster!
Lower Decks might actually be my favorite Star Trek, period. Including DS9 and TNG.
I watch it BECAUSE it's woke.
Yes. Subtle, nuanced, and in no way obvious.
Which episode is this?
TOS s2e19 "A Private Little War" a rather in your face allegory for the then still active Vietnam War.
This is the exact episode I think about for all the "it's so woke now" folks.
MFing Boomers didn't fucking get it, did they?
Boomers were born between 1946 and 1964. Original Star Trek aired 1966 to 1969, so those "MFing Boomers" grew up watching the original series, and many like Michael Piller and Hilary Bader wrote episodes for The Next Generation. I think they get it fine and you're just an ass.
That's not what I'm saying.
I'm saying that Boomers, as you correctly pointed out, watched the show growing up. And that for many of them, the "woke" stuff just sailed right over their heads at warp factor 14.1 (a joke that works because TOS didn't have the TNG and after warp 10=infinite speed convention).
If Boomers understood the presence of often heavy-handed social critique on TOS the first time around, facebook posts about "when did Star Trek get woke?" wouldn't really get very far. Of course, many Boomers were children at the time, focused on the scifi elements and not social issues in the plot. I watched TNG when I was a kid, and I'm sure I missed some of the less heavy-handed social critique. However, Boomers in general are vocal about things like this, and how their remembrances of things from the hallowed era of the 1960's are undeniable, even though factually incomplete.
Gotten woke? Hmmm ... no, it has always pioneered diversity. Lucille Ball helped get Star Trek started, and she was obviously into diversity.
People who accuse Star Trek of being woke fall into two camps. Either they never liked it or they loved it before the Trump era.
For the latter, they’re accusing Star Trek of being woke to try to distract from or argue against the fact that they’re embracing prejudice. As if to say: It’s not me, Star Trek has changed.
No. It’s you. You’re the villain here.
They honestly don't get it most of the time. It's an honestly horrifying the lack of comprehension of any art form that uses nuance of any sort. It'd like a face blind person that can't recognize their own spouse until they speak, level of unaware.
Whaaaaaat, Star Trek is woke?
Well its time to sleep for me anyway, good night.
/c/TenForward: Your home-away-from-home for all things Star Trek!
Re-route power to the shields, emit a tachyon pulse through the deflector, and post all the nonsense you want. Within reason of course.
~ 1. No bigotry. This is a Star Trek community. Remember that diversity and coexistence are Star Trek values. Any post/comments that are racist, anti-LGBT, or generally "othering" of a group will result in removal/ban.
~ 2. Keep it civil. Disagreements will happen both on lore and preferences. That's okay! Just don't let it make you forget that the person you are talking to is also a person.
~ 3. Use spoiler tags.
Use spoiler tags in comments, and NSFW checkbox for posts.
This applies to any episodes that have dropped within 3 months prior of your posting. After that it's free game.
~ 4. Keep it Trek related. This one is kind of a gimme but keep as on topic as possible.
~ 5. Keep posts to a limit. We all love Star Trek stuff but 3-4 posts in an hour is plenty enough.
~ 6. Try to not repost. Mistakes happen, we get it! But try to not repost anything from within the past 1-2 months.
~ 7. No General AI Art. Posts of simple AI art do not 'inspire jamaharon'
~ 8. No Political Upheaval. Political commentary is allowed, but please keep discussions civil. Read here for our community's expectations.
Fun will now commence.
Sister Communities:
Want your community to be added to the sidebar? Just ask one of our mods!
Creator Resources:
Looking for a Star Trek screencap? (TrekCore)
Looking for the right Star Trek typeface/font for your meme? (Thank you @kellyaster for putting this together!)
