If you mean the Mayfield shop specifically, it's not open yet. I've been to their other location on Steel St, though, and they've always been good, yeah. Website here: https://www.antojitos.com.au/

But the main point of this post, to explain for non-Novocastrians, is that they've adapted the semi-iconic signage of the pie shop that was there for many years previous to this. You can still see it on Google Maps.

The unconventional use of punctuation sticks in the brain when you drive past it on a daily basis:

YES !! REAL STEAK PIES

"COOKED DAILY"