you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 3 points 15 hours ago (2 children)

it was also never about keeping the government in check. at the time of the founding fathers, the primary threats to democracy in the us were the major world powers of the time, such as the british or the french, taking an issue with that kingless freedom project overseas. both of those did actually attack the us post-1791.

keeping the populace armed is fairly worthless against internal tyrants, there are plenty of places in the world with autocratic rule and easy access to firearms, and the us itself is also an oligarchy at this point, despite being chock-full of guns. guns don't make you democratic, they just modify how power is gained and brokered.

but an armed populace is much harder for an external aggressor to attack than a disarmed one, so when your democracy is stable internally but contested externally, guns do in fact help with that. but that was a very specific scenario in history, and in the present day, there are no external threats to the us. keeping the american populace armed has lost its usefulness long ago.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 3 hours ago (1 child)

    it was also never about keeping the government in check.

    It very much was, though -- that's why the bit about the militias is in there. When the second amendment was first mooted, it was also being proposed that the federal army would be limited constitutionally to no more than 16,000 men. The individual state militias in combination would always be much larger than that in total, so the second amendment would effectively prevent the federal government from banning the militias and thus constituting the largest military power in the country.

    It has subsequently been reinterpreted very differently by the supreme court so none of this is really relevant today (there are no militias any more, obviously), but you can't say it was "never" about keeping the (federal) government in check.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment