If they're trying to objectively evaluate someone's skills that's exactly what you would want to do. If you have to come up with a different criteria for every submission then it starts to become subjective quickly.

Check out 90% of woodworking posts, logic holds up.

That everyone else knows is pain in the dickhole to make? Yeah, works well, actually.

As is tradition!

but.. tradition is peer pressure from dead people.

and.. dead people turn into zombies.

Ipso facto, you better make it or zombies will take your lunch money.

Logically sound reasoning.