So, brought on by this thread:
https://hexbear.net/post/8986189?scrollToComments=false
And @EdlritchEconomics@hexbear.net pointing out it's a AI image; here is a whole thing.
So I think the general consensus is AI slop bad and we dont want it in this town.
AI slop is now a bit tricky and I wouldnt blame someone for being tricked and posting slop as if it were real because they were themselves mislead. I dont blame em, scrutinizing every image is an exhausting ordeal.
So my proposal, is that any AI slop presented as true should be removed. Posting AI slop to comment on AI slop seems fine and honest. I dont think anyone posting AI slop and presenting it as real should face consequences unless there is evidence of doing it on purpose but we cant have robot pictures pretending to be real pictures. We need Blade Runners.
I dunno if a task force or an if you see something say something method is best, but it's just gonna get harder to spot for a while until the whole thing turns into a fun house mirror, so it seems worth getting in front of. You shouldn't have to scroll the comments to find out a posted image is AI and I would prefer no image posted here be AI unless it's meant to comment on that image as an AI image, illustrating a point about a slop image is one thing but if an image is AI I think it should just be removed but ill accept a tag being needed.
I picked Chat cause I dunno if anyone uses Feedback nowadays.
This also just made me think of photoshopping pictures to make them look like AI for plausible deniability/for a bit
Transparency is what matters. If a poster is conned as well though, they need to edit as soon as it's made known.
Trying to pass off slop as original content you created should be bannable imo.
But why allow any AI slop at all? Aside from reposting to laugh at? I get posting AI slop found elsewhere to make fun of and think thst is fine. But posters tricked by AI should have the post removed, with no hard feelings. Spotting it is also gonna be more difficult until the bubble bursts so I think it might be good to get a a Nerds Who Are Good At Spotting AI task force to nip things at the bud. I dont wanna punish anyone who is posting AI cause they were duped. It's built to trick you. If intentionality is evident kill em. Any AI image post that isnt badically there to shit talk the ai image shouldnt be here and even then should get a tag
I think removal is fine for non-malicous posting of slop without a tag. Either tag it (and yes, agreed that reposting for mockery is fine) or having it removed or, if the attempt was malicious ("look at what I made"), ban of some amount.
I would prefer No Ai unless its a screenshot and in mockery policy and even mockery posts should be tagged. I don't any AI on hexbear that isnt in that specific zone, personally. I don't think even reposting ai content that is treated as positive or neutral should be allowed even if tagged. No slop zone.