I think I figured it out, his head or at least face is too babyish. I don't know if it's because he's had work done or if he is just unlucky but his eyes up are normal ish but below his eyes are weirdly rounded. The edits often unify the rounding of his face resulting in him not looking so weird.

Though his head shape as a whole is kinda off regardless I think it's the weird assymetrical nature of his face that causes the surreal look.