1
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 26 May 2023
1 points (100.0% liked)
mutual_aid
21977 readers
46 users here now
Users cannot assume that any post has been vetted and must do their own investigation.
RULES:
- All mutual aid requests must go in this community.
- Mods do not vet individual mutual aid requests. Donate at your own risk.
- Do not request donations for funding anything explicitly illegal.
- Comments giving unsolicited advice will be removed. (See below)
- Comments or posts that are critical of any mutual aid post or user will be removed. (See below)
- Posts containing opsec leaks will be removed.
Additionally:
-
If you are open to non-monetary aid please indicate so in your post
-
If you wish to provide unsolicited advice/resources, then please make a separate post in this community
-
Other types of non-specific meta posts about other users may be made in the [email protected] community
-
If you have concrete evidence of something even remotely suspicious, do not hesitate to bring it to the attention of a moderator for review via direct message
-
We strongly advise you ask people to send you a direct message to obtain information regarding payment to prevent inadvertent opsec leaks.
-
Please consider posting once a day and editing the title of a mutual aid post to include [Covered] or [Need Met] when a request has been satisfied or goal met.
-
Consider not making comments about receiving large donations, or about what that money is spent on.
Moderator Pinning Rules:
-
Moderators are strictly prohibited from promoting/endorsing/pinning individual mutual aid requests (especially those of their own) as this creates unfair post visibility and could therefore benefit more from that than the standard user. Moderators caught engaging in this behavior will be swiftly removed from the moderator board with extreme prejudice.
-
Moderators are allowed to pin and crosspost donation requests for large scope issues such as natural disaster relief funds and bail funds ((Example)[https://hexbear.net/post/16574) along with other crowd or moderator-compiled informational resources pertaining to donating or volunteering (Example), so long as the utmost due diligence is done prior to endorsement, especially in the case of directing people to donate to non-profit organizations.
-
Financial documents of non-profit organizations available to the public must be heavily scrutinized before moderator endorsement, and links to those must also be included in the endorsement post to help the community make their own decision if they should donate.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
~~Back in the days of Marx and Engels this was known as Owenism and there's a critique of it in Socialism: Utopian and Scientific. It has been tried, including in the US.~~
~~For a more modern critique check out https://kites-journal.org/2021/11/01/revolution-has-vanished-replaced-with-fantasies-of-dual-power-counterpower-base-areas-abolition-and-other-bottom-up-bourgeois-democratic-illusions/~~
~~Basically you can't just cut yourself off from the capitalist system, and trying to create cooperative structures that coexist outside of capitalism just turns into better conditions inside the system for the members of your coop while dampening revolutionary consciousness. When you try to turn those structures into revolutionary vehicles they run into problems.~~
edit: oops damn shouldn't have posted the mutual-aid-isn't-communism take in the c/mutual_aid, that's what I get for sorting by new
Honestly, I don't want it to be a revolutionary vehicle for the whole system, I'd rather just help people escape -- and if we can prove firsthand that mutual aid works and we can insulate society against manipulation and power grabbing, maybe normal people would see it as a possibility for once. I think our country is bound too tightly by its shared cultural mythology to do anything meaningful. Expecting to fix the whole world, seems to me like a fool's game. Even while people recognize the abuses of the economic upper class, their minds are closed to understanding the cultural upper-class, composed of successful psychopaths and their sycophants leading everyone else by the nose. Such a culture cannot be fixed, you can only help people escape and survive until everyone else's illusion collapses sufficiently for them to adapt to the danger they were unwilling to see, which may not even be possible on a large scale in today's world.
You would have thought 10 years ago, that if everyone learned the most powerful people in the country, the ones who lead politicians, were involved in CSA / trafficking, everyone would lose their shit and force the system's hand to at least assert this one basic moral expectation -- right? Turns out that is not the case. They can manufacture consent for everything up to and including that. It's a lost cause at that point. There is no future in trying to convince people who don't wanna be convinced or helped imho
Reading the article, it looks like the main criticism is that this sort of work doesn't directly help the revolution. If you're planning to do this just to help people you should be fine, it probably won't help bring about communism but you will be helping real people that need help and need it now.
But if you agree that such activity isn't building for the revolution and still decide that's what you should really be spending your time on, then you are a liberal.
Well not all of us can be as pure a leftist as you are. I look forward to seeing your progress in building communism.
Bro I'm just asking you to join us figuring out the right approach. You don't have to be defensive about the fact we don't have a vanguard party yet, but pretending that we can just keep doing what hasn't worked before is just not the way to go.
Neither is calling someone a liberal because they want to create a democratically run commune for people in need. That's way too much direct action for a liberal and requires a ton of work and any knowledge gained on living sustainably with a group of like minded people would be useful to any revolutionary group, especially when things are in flux post revolution when things will probably be very precarious. While it may not be building the revolution, there are things that can be done to support it: if everyone is busy building the revolution you'll starve to death after it happens
I don't think so? If revolution turns out to be unfeasible due to the speed of modern technological advancement fueling pre-existing power structures, and betterment by reform is off the table due to the mounting power of propaganda, leftists need to be more creative about their praxis. Creating a lifeline for migrants and refugees to get back up on their feet and live within an economically democratic community seems like the only praxis that can help anyone, based on what I've seen.
I think arguing that revolution is impossible so we should just focus on helping right some of the most egregious wrongs, also counts as liberalism...
We can work towards revolutionary change, but the fact is your entire life will go by and you will never see a real revolution. Waiting for revolution is the leftist equivalent of waiting for the day Jesus returns to earth.