this post was submitted on 03 Mar 2025
22 points (69.6% liked)
World News
35402 readers
491 users here now
News from around the world!
Rules:
-
Please only post links to actual news sources, no tabloid sites, etc
-
No NSFW content
-
No hate speech, bigotry, propaganda, etc
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
US did not ever have slavery! Because noone was slave there except black people if they were not free.
Some hard hitting facts right there. I betcha you didnt know this.
Since you really need this argument made;
To have slavery requires a minority to be enslaved. Not all us citizens needs to be slaves for the description to apply. To have slavery means to have all free people with an exception of a minority of slaves.
To have open borders requires a majority of people the be free to pass from them. Not all citizens need to be able to pass for the description to apply. To have open borders means to allow all people with an exception of a minority to pass.
This is as far as I will go to debate this stupid argument. Anyone with at least two braincells with understand my position.
I understand your position.
But I think, to have open borders, it needs to be much more than a mere majority that are free to cross the border. "Military aged males" are a huge portion of the population, eyeballing it I'm coming up with 1/5th of the entire country.
If millions of people can't leave, there aren't open borders.
First halve that because you are only talking about exiting. Foreigns can enter and exit. Ukrainians can enter. People who cannot be conscripted can exit (women, too old, too disabled, guardians, single fathers, athletes, students etc). Ukraine is at war. I would say that 100% of people who should be able to pass can pass. The claim that Ukraine "DOES NOT have open borders" is false or grossly misleading.
Wow, your every comment is better than the previous one.
You would be the person saying "I would say that 100% of people who should be free are free" just a small time ago in USA...
You are the best example of why liberals are the most anti-liberty and pro-discrimination people out there.
A one way border isn't exactly open and saying it is is what is grossly misleading.
"Why are you calling this facility a prison? Sure, you cannot leave, but at least you can ENTER!"
Yeah the US clearly has an open southern border. How could you not see that? /s
I'm dumb, i need to clarify this. so for the people that cannot pass, is it open borders or closed borders?
Open borders. Just not for them.
What's so special about 50%? Why not set the bar at 60% or 40%? Or 99% or 1%?
Alright so if I understand this well: Haiti under the French colonial rule did not have slavery during the times when the imported slave population exceeded some limit when compared to the French population there.
I will continue with a hypothetical: if for example more French came on a trip there and the not slaves would become a minority, there would all of a sudden be slavery there. And of course when they would depart from their holidays, Haiti would again gracefully abandon that heinous practice.