this post was submitted on 31 Dec 2024
373 points (95.2% liked)
196
16793 readers
2054 users here now
Be sure to follow the rule before you head out.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Aren't generations separated by 30ish years?
This is a farce.
I’ve heard 20. Wikipedia says 20-30.
14 seems short.
It’s all kind of silly since human reproduction is continuous.
It's a bit like the notions of pre-modern, modern, and post-modern. The change was continuous over a long period of time, but I think there are commonalities of thought and experience that tie generations together. Pearl Harbor, the Vietnam War, the fall of the Berlin Wall, 9/11; all of those influenced people of different ages at the time in different ways, compounding on each other.
The perspective of someone who was 18 on 9/11/2001 was different from someone who was 35, versus someone who was 50, versus someone who was 80. My kids, for example, have never known the WTC as anything other than an attack site, and recoiled when the NYC skyline was shown during New Year's Rockin' Eve 1999.
Exactly.
It’s that shift in perspective and experience that defines a generation and there are generation-bounding events like 9/11. But the period of time is not precise, and generally much longer than 14 years.
Continuous? Then why do i keep releasing a series of humo-eggs every 20 years?
Have you tried not doing that?
Wait why wouldn't I?
Should I not be?
Nah it's whatever, you do you boo
Weren't they defined by major cultural events? Zoomers not remembering 9/11 for example
The short answer is "no." The long answer is:
This is one of those cultural things that I tend to get grump and annoyed about because it's stupid and people pretend that it's real.
This is why people 'forget about gen x' imo, it's because there wasn't a single cultural event that aligned people in the gap between boomers (the baby boom, which resulted in a lot of people being a similar age to form a cohort) and millennials (wide spread access to rapidly developing internet, 9/11, and the dot com bubble happening during formative years)
That's just my opinion though, I know lots of stuff happened in that time, but I think those examples are standout events. (This is my perspective from the US, so things like the Berlin wall, I think had a less significant immediate effect on people here, culturally)
Gen X had their formative years at the height of the cold war, when it felt like the world could end at any moment due to a dumb mistake.
My paranoid side says it's likely the seed of another "us vs. them" situation, like how boomers are blaming every wrong in the world on millenials.
I thought it was 20ish years i.e. the average time it takes for babies to reach adulthood and have kids.
Although to be fair I don't actually know what the average is. It might be 30 for all I know lol