An Imgur link was detected in your comment. Here are links to the same location on alternative frontends that protect your privacy.

• imgur.artemislena.eu
• rimgo.projectsegfau.lt
• imgin.voidnet.tech

Yeah S4A called China a "social democracy" and said it was practicing "pseudo-national liberation" (a surprisingly vague term that I do not think was expanded upon in the video that it came from: https://youtu.be/o2AcXOsRkyQ), so they are definitely some ultra. I do not believe I have ever heard Red Pen, though.

I don't like the term revisionism. I think in the context of the second international, when there were opportunistic tendencies in the SPD that wanted to deviate from the revolutionary strategy, I think calling out revisionism made a lot of sense. Revisionism was a real danger and basically sabotaged the revolutionary movement in Germany and Europe, which was growing strong at the time.

Afterwards, I think this "revisionism" turned into a senseless accusation that caused many different socialist/communist groups to start factionalizing and splitting into smaller and smaller groups, to the point that all of them became insignificant or isolated.

In the case of China, it's not as if there aren't real contradictions in the Chinese development. Yes, China has a bourgeoisie, and many petite bourgeois tendencies growing among the middle classes. Yes, China coexists in the same imperialist system which other neoliberal powers operate. China exports capital to Brazil and to many countries in the Global South and North.

However, China also was able to restrict the bourgeoisie into a cage so they don't go out of hand. They also seized control of financial capital by the state to avoid the trap of having the economy being dominated by speculators. China's economy is very reliant on planning, and with this was able to avoid the profit rate pitfall that caused many developed global north nations to desindudtrialize.

So, I'd say that China is just China. It still has many contradictions. The contradiction between capital and labor hasn't been overcome yet. The contradiction of unequal development still exists between China and other global South countries. But, still we better have China than not have it.

In the end, China is not going to save us. We need to undergo our own revolutionary processes, even if our countries and our movements enter in contradiction with China.