Muslims need to chill on the alcohol taboo (lemmy.ca)

submitted 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

0 comments fedilink hide all child comments

By: u/Brown_Leviathan

Ibn Battuta, the famous medieval Muslim traveller, narrated how he accidentally drank alcoholic beer with fellow Muslims during his travels, when he was in Turkey. This happened because the local people followed the Hanafi school of thought, which allowed grain-based alcohol, while Ibn Battuta's Maliki school forbade all alcoholic beverages. In his own words, "When I went out I made enquiry about it and they said 'It is nabidh [a fermented drink] which they make from dugi grain.' These people are Hanafis and nabidh is permissible according to their doctrine."

The Qur'an uses the word "Khamr" for prohibited alcoholic beverages. According to some early scholars like Abu Hanifa, "Khamr" literally means wine made of grapes or dates, and does not include not all other drinks. According to Abu Hanifa, alcoholic beverages made from honey, figs, wheat, maize or barley are permissible if consumed below the point of intoxication. Later Hanafi scholars eventually abrogated Abu Hanifa's ruling and adopted a general prohibition of all alcoholic beverages, most likely due to pressure from other schools of jurisprudence.

The early Kufan Hanafi jurist Ibrâhîm al-Nakha'î (d. 96/715-6) asserts that the public has misinterpreted the Prophet's statement that drinks "that intoxicate in large quantities are forbidden in small quantities" (i.e., the 'large/small' tradition)." Ibrahim explains that the Prophet meant to forbid intoxication rather than intoxicants.

The prominent Maliki jurist Ibn Rushd al-Jadd (d. 520/1126) states that "Khamr is that which intoxicates and overwhelms the intellect". There is a controversial and disputed narration, wherein the Prophet instructs Abu Musa to "drink but do not become Intoxicated". (Ibn Rushd al-Hafid, Bidaya, 2:914)

It is also well known that the famous Muslim philosopher and physician Ibn Sina (Avicenna) would often drink wine. He acknowledged the health benefits of drinking wine in moderation.

It is often claimed that Ottoman sultan-caliph Abdülhamid II would occasionally and privately savor a glass of cognac at his doctors’ orders.

A few years ago, a prominent Qatar-based Muslim scholar, Yousuf Al Qaradawi declared:

“An alcohol volume of up to 5/1000 or 0.5% in a drink has no significance in making it haram [prohibited]. It is a very small quantity, especially if it results from natural fermentation and is not manufactured."

Considering the totality of facts and arguments, I would say that the strict level of taboo and prohibition that today Islamic scholars have imposed upon the Muslims was not always the case historically.

Let me know what you guys think.

Please refer to:

'Angels Tapping at the Wine-shop's Door: A History of Alcohol in the Islamic World' by Rudi Matthee.
Haider, N. (2013). Contesting intoxication: Early juristic debates over the lawfulness of alcoholic beverages. Islamic L. & Soc'y, 20, 48.
'The Odyssey of Ibn Battuta: Uncommon Tales of a Medieval Adventurer', by David Waines

no comments (yet)

sorted by: hot top new old

there doesn't seem to be anything here

this post was submitted on 04 Jul 2025

3 points (80.0% liked)

Progressive_Islam

58 readers

31 users here now

(Formerly Lemm.ee)

Description

A place for Progressive Muslims of all sects and schools of thought. We seek to foster an atmosphere of understanding, tolerance, and peace between all peoples.

Community Rules

Be respectful of one another

Please treat others with respect. Being respectful means :

listening, even if strongly disagree;
being thoughtful of other people's feelings;
assuming that things are said in good faith (unless otherwise indicated);
addressing mistakes, errors, or shortcomings with kindness;
make decisions based upon what is right, not who or what you like;
live and let live (i.e., don't condemn people to death or suffering because they have chosen a different lifestyle).

We do not promote ultra conservative ideas

Although Discussion around mainstream conservative Islamic theology is allowed in this community, we do not allow promotion of such conservative ideas. Therefore, posts & comments that promote such ultra-conservative ideas & websites will be removed.

All contributions should be made in good faith

Contributing in good faith means being open to considering the arguments made by the other side, either in whole or in part. Rather than rejecting the entire progressive/conservative argument, what parts of the argument can you agree upon? Posts simply aiming to antagonize, preach, or pronounce takfir over an individual or group would are obvious examples of bad faith contributions.

Don't proselytize

Submissions seeking to proselytize other religions or no religion, or promoting one sect or denomination over others will be removed. Posts/Comments linking to non-lslamic or Salafist sources may be removed where such links might serve to legitimize kufr, Salafist, or extremist modes of thinking.

No flamewars, dramas, or brigading other Lemmy communities

While memes, screenshots, and images involving other Lemmy communities are permitted, any identifying features must be omitted or censored. Please black out or obscure any username.

If you are posting images or screenshots of other social media websites then censoring names isn't necessary.

Memes (weekends only), screenshots, and other images

While memes, screenshots, and images involving other communities are permitted, any identifying features must be omitted or censored. Please black out or obscure any usernames. Also, memes may only be posted on weekends.

Violations of Community rules 3 times within the period of 6 months will result in a Community ban

At their discretion, moderators may issue up to three warnings for rule violations before banning a user. Be aware that more serious offenses (e.g., violating your User Agreement with Lemmy) may result in an instant and permanent ban. Moreover, "at the discretion of the moderators" means that the moderators may opt to permanently ban any user without prior warning if they deem the rule violation to be particularly serious.

We have zero tolerance for hate speech

We will remove any content promoting violence or hatred against individuals or groups based on any of the following attributes:

Age
Disability
Ethnicity
Gender identity
Gender expression
Nationality
Race
Immigration Status
Religion (incl. sect)
Sex/Gender
Sexual orientation

Use English

All users are required to use English in all posts and parent comments. Users must provide an English translation if posting materials from non-English sources. Videos must either be in English or have English subtitles. We also understand that certain non-English words are part of the standard discourse of Islam and as such some discretion some non-English words are allowed without translation (e.g., Allah).

Replying to the parent comments in other languages is allowed

Mental Health Rule

We are not a mental health service. Please be aware that content may be removed if the community has concerns about the mental health or wellbeing of a user. We reserve the right to contact Lemmy admin should a user express thoughts about suicide or serious self-harm. In some cases, users expressing extreme levels of anxiety around a religious issue may be asked to consult with either an Islamic scholar or a mental health professional, depending upon the circumstances.

Report the trolls and move on

Please do not engage with trolls. While trolls are sometimes difficult to detect and to discern from genuine posters, if you believe that you have encountered a troll, please cut off all contact. Report and move on. You know the saying: "Don't feed the trolls"!

Suspicious account activity

Accounts may be banned if there is a marked incongruence between account age and account karma. We have taken this step to cull farmed troll accounts.

WIKI: https://reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/w/index

TOPIC INDEX: https://malmtopicindex.wordpress.com/index/

NOTEWORTHY: https://reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/w/archive

BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS: https://reddit.com/r/progressive_islam/w/recommended_reading

RECOMENDED YOUTUBE CHANNELS:

Let the Quran Speak: https://m.youtube.com/user/QuranSpeaks

Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning: https://m.youtube.com/channel/UC1isGGyqPXxGb3i_Tr6agHg

Mufti Abu Layth: https://m.youtube.com/user/MadinanPath

Adnan Ibrahim: https://m.youtube.com/user/shaikhAdnanIbrahim

The Usuli Institute: https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCacZ3k2AOpd5-3tdCxcDmgQ

Search For Beauty: https://m.youtube.com/user/TheScholarofthehouse

Qur'anic Islam: https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCu4AdsljkcfdGYm8kqi3Bzw