Badge of honor
this post was submitted on 30 Apr 2025
31 points (97.0% liked)
Europe
4565 readers
77 users here now
Europa
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
top 10 comments
sorted by:
hot
top
controversial
new
old
A festival is a celebration of music, community and humanity. It can bring everyone together in peace. Bringing division with your agendas goes against everything a festival stands for. Tying your political stance to your attendance at a festival is foolish.
That said there's a lot of mean folk in power, trying to shut down anyone who is against ~~warmongers and terrorists~~ the Israeli government's cruel crusade, and this was possibly that.
I think people might be misreading your comment and you’re actually criticizing the festival hosts not the band right?
I find it ridiculous to invite e.g. Irish bands and then be surprised that they take a stance against genocide and colonization. To me it’s really a badge of honor for anyone to get canceled for being pro-Palestine.
Of course it's a badge of honour, the opposite stance would be to be pro genocide... YSK, Kneecap took that stance multiple times before they were famous, very much at their own expense.
Nah, I'm criticising the band for bringing their views into what's supposed to be a neutral zone. I prefer the politically charged announcements be kept for political stages. The hosts might actually share their opinion, but taking any kind of stance that naturally divides the people right now can incite dissent or violence (especially if it annoys the pro-genociders). Being cancelled for standing up for your morals and against cruelty is absolutely honourable!
"Politics is when people talk about things which do not affect white people"
A festival is a celebration of music, community and humanity.
Music, as with all art forms, can powerfully express emotion, including reaction to policy and politics. Communities cannot survive and thrive by ignoring its politics. And therefore nor can humanity. My point being, to be apolitical isn't inherently good for music, community nor humanity, and when it comes to supporting a genocide or apartheid and other inhuman antisocial behavior, that's a division worth making to benefit community and humanity.
Obviously it's fine to seek and enjoy less political works, I often do, but it's strange to suggest that artists should repress their politics in their art performance. Kneecap has made no secret that they are an anti-colonial republicanist act, naming themselves in reference to an IRA practice.
Thank you. Any kind of repression is unhealthy, which is one reason why I'm against some republican/conservative beliefs. I was trying to see it from the organisers' point of view.
Unfortunately, it seems that announcing their progressive views ahead of attendance at Kneecap, a host that openly prefers regression, only resulted in rejection on account of said host's intent to reject any view that doesn't align with their own.