6
submitted 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

February 13th 2025,

Back to research class and today sucked. Okay, it wasn’t that bad but I had a hard time because I did not read the article. This was sort of on purpose, not because I did not want to read it, but because I was busy doing an assignment for my work placement class.

This was not a good decision on my end because when class started he separated us into groups, my nightmare, and told us to do the analyzing work for him. And to feel free to shame those who didn’t read the article. Fuck me i guess.

So each group had to do a certain cluster of questions that were based on a specific theme of analysis. By that I mean one group had to figure out the research question while another had to figure out the argument. I was in the argument group.

My fellow students were talking about the article while i just sat there reading, trying to answer the questions even though I hadn’t read it yet. Command F helps. I was definitely the weakest link/the member everyone dreads having. To be honest, even if I had read the article I probably would’ve said anything anyway.

The article we had to read was “Mosques and Markets” and “Black Flags in the Bazaar: The Making of Modern Islamist Proto-states” by Aisha Ahmed. Apparently my professor was there during the book launch. The main idea of this book was to take aim at traditional International Relations analysis, she had issues with the existing literature on Islamist issues, she believes that the idea that Islam is more inherently violent than envy other religion is bullshit. She also found it odd that nobody had made the connection between big businesses and Islamist groups.

top 2 comments
sorted by: hot top new old
[-] [email protected] 2 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

she believes that the idea that Islam is nor inherently violent than envy other religion is bullshit.

Did you mean ‘Islam is not inherently more violent than any other religion’?

Your professor should seek out Under Crescent and Cross: The Jews in the Middle Ages, if she has not done so already. It carefully compares and contrasts the situations that Jews had within Christian states and Islamic ones, and even in the sporadic cases where a Muslim was motivated by anti-Judaism, the consequences were less severe and less far-reaching than similar cases in Christendom.

With the exception of some Qurʻanic verses, there is nothing ‘inherently’ violent in Islam. For example, when Judaists and Christians had to pay jizya, it was customary for the tax collectors to slap the taxpayers’ necks, but this law, and by extension hitting the taxpayers’ necks, is now defunct. Likewise, while some Muslims think that capital punishment is an acceptable response to apostasy, many other Muslims oppose such a penalty as wildly inappropriate. Even penile circumcision has a few Muslim opponents, but they are in the minority (for now).

I could go on, but I am guessing that you know most of this already. I do find it odd, though, that I have never once seen Muslim-bashers bring up penile circumcision or even the Ottoman Empire’s massacres of Armenians and Assyrians. I think that blaming anything squarely on the shoulders of Islam or any other faith is misguided, but I could have understood why somebody would bring up those particular subjects when griping about Islam, yet somehow I have never seen that happen.

[-] [email protected] 3 points 5 months ago

I actually meant “more”, so her argument is that Islam is NOT inherently more violent than other religions, which is contrary to the common western (racist) narrative.

this post was submitted on 17 Feb 2025
6 points (100.0% liked)

Chronicles of SpaceDogs

43 readers
1 users here now

A community dedicated to organizing the writings of my time at university.

I am making these posts to not only document my experiences for myself, but to also share with my fellow comrades and hopefully shed some light on what its like in academia.

Most posts will be centred around my Political Science and History classes but may also reference other courses if relevant.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS