California’s AB 994 is a newly instituted piece of legislation that significantly regulates the protocol for police departments and sheriff’s offices in relation to the publication of mugshots on their social media platforms. This law, effective from January 1, 2024, introduces strict controls regarding the display of mugshots, particularly emphasizing the inclusion of the arrested individual’s self-identified name and gendered pronouns.
We obtained a copy of the bill for you here (PDF).
Under AB 994, the conditions allowing for the sharing of mugshots on social media by law enforcement are notably restricted. The law mandates that the person’s chosen name and chosen pronouns be used when their mugshot is uploaded on these platforms. This requirement is applicable regardless of the nature of the alleged crime.
“With respect to an individual who has been arrested for any crime, this bill would require a police department or sheriff’s office, upon posting a booking photo on social media, to use the name and pronouns given by the individual arrested,” the law specifically states.
Law enforcement agencies, however, retain the discretion to use other legal names or aliases in situations where it may aid in apprehending the individual, reduce imminent threats to public safety, or in other urgent scenarios.
Traditionally, the booking process after an arrest involves using the person’s legal name from official documents like birth certificates or driver’s licenses. The new legislation, however, stipulates these new rules specifically for the phase when the individual’s mugshot is posted online.
AB 994 also sets boundaries on the posting of mugshots for those accused of nonviolent crimes. The exceptions to this limitation include instances where the release of the image could contribute to the person’s capture, mitigate threats to others, or is ordered by a judge.
Furthermore, the law requires the removal of all mugshots from law enforcement social media accounts within two weeks, unless it falls under the same three exceptional categories.
They haven't even been convicted yet, they're supposed to enjoy the presumption of innocence, and yet they're being shamed and punished.
The dead naming really isn't cool either, although that's probably bottom of the list of worries trans people have when interacting with the police given the horror stories I've heard.
Arrest records are public record and for good reason. You don't want the police to be able to arrest someone and dissappear them.
This article and my comment are about mugshots not arrest records. But it is good that you point out why arrest records are important.