I be you do know plenty of guys that do, it's easy to assume everyone thinks like you but that's not how humans work.

As a man, I agree. I think it's more that if it's noticable make up, it's probably too much, and that's the only kind most men notice. I personally don't care about the things you mentioned, however I do appreciate eyeliner and hair dyes (as long as it isn't damaged to a crisp). Otherwise, just generally looking healthy and hygienic is important.

I'm a guy who really likes all of those, and heavier make-up looks in general. I wouldn't ever expect someone to wear them just for me though. I see makeup as something that's 90% for the person wearing it, and making them feel good about themselves. Same goes for lighter or no make-up looks. The confidence from feeling good about yourself is far more important than whatever "look" you go for.