5
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 26 Apr 2026
5 points (69.2% liked)
USA | United states of America
287 readers
1 users here now
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
To be fair...
America outlawed the type of labor force that China uses to do that.
https://thehill.com/policy/international/5344318-china-rare-earth-minerals-uyghur/
You make it sound like communal work "for the greater good"...
It's literal slave labor in horrible conditions where the Chinese government doesn't care how fast it kills the slaves.
Okay, thanks for the addition. Let’s be honest, if there was a lot of profit in this, it wouldn’t be stopped. China did it for control of a crucial market.
Nope, simply stating basically why each one doesn’t. I’m well aware it’s slave Labor in some parts and I know Chiba doesn’t give a shit. Not everywhere. We used to extract rare earths in Australia as well and it wasn’t staff treatment or abuse that stooped it here, it was environmental opposition.
Huh?
If:
America had these deposits
Had slave labor
Had zero environmental regulations
They could do what China is doing...
And we're heading that way and may be doing it too soon.
We could do it today if it wasnt for all those pesky human rights and environmental regulations. /s
America does have the deposits. Granted, they’re concentrated in certain parts of the world but they can be extracted from most soils.
America has a lot of minerals. It gets overshadowed sometimes by Canada, the Gulf and us to a degree but it’s loaded too. I know this because I’ve worked with American geologists, engineers etc both in exploration and gas production; I’m a surveyor. I also know that money drives it all. We are good at finding it and pulling it out, you blokes are exceptional at refining it and engineering the equipment to produce it.
This is the US. If it was viable, either that law wouldn’t exist or they’d improve the conditions enough to do it. If I have to give Americans credit for something, it’s can do if you put money in front of them. Nothing stands in the way of American miners, energy companies and money. We’re listening to them whine in Australia now under Senate inquiry because our lucky country government was too stupid to tax gas properly. That said, I can’t blame them or the Japanese, it was a terrific opportunity.
Not so long ago they hit us up to see if we were interested in accelerating rare earth exploration.
Edit: America has slave Labor too; it’s just dressed in imprisonment and undocumented migrants.
No...
You're saying way too much at once thats wildly incorrect and not based on fact that I can't explain the why/how of you being so wrong.
If you want to actually learn, ask one question at a time politely and people may help you.
Weird choice to reply 11 hours to say you don't want to "engage"...
You could have just not replied, and then 100% not gotten another teply