So I think we’d all agree that if people were being herded onto boxcars and delivered to incinerators that would clearly be a time for violence. Not happening right now (that we know of), but our homegrown Führer may change his whim at any moment. My question is “What is the line that makes violent protest acceptable?” The first time a cop shoots a protestor? Military does it? Does the shot need to be fatal? Life altering (think paralyzing)? And if so, why does it have to at a point where it’s SO MUCH HARDER to come back from, as opposed to now? Which wouldn’t be easy, mind you, but their positions aren’t fully fortified yet, so better than 6 months, a year from now. Especially when we can all see where it’s going, to the point of inevitability. And before I get called out on that, any criticism needs to include exactly how the critic sees this de-escalating in any other manner.
Hoping for some thought provoking discussion here, because let’s face it - Republican actions are making things go downhill fast.
Here’s what I was taught: the line when aggressive action happens is once “class consciousness” is achieved. Basically, class consciousness is this theoretical moment where a critical mass is achieved where enough citizens realize the bonds that the current ruling class puts on them are harmful and are only effective because the ruled class accepts those bonds.
After that, the ruled decide collectively not to be complicit in their own enslavement anymore (usually via collective non-violent action) and this usually causes the ruling class to commit violence in retaliation against the ruled. This creates martyrs and sympathy towards the ruled class’ cause and then… revolution (usually via coup). Then the cycle starts again with a new ruling class (that temporarily has the favor of the people).
I actually thought this process was beginning in the US with the United Healthcare CEO slaying. If they hadn’t caught Luigi, I believe there would have eventually been other attacks on the Bourgeoisie.
So how does it de-escalate? Well, a ton can happen and humans are very odd. It could be the case that some folk hero from the ruled class gains enough popularity that they are able to enact some kind of reform to benefit the ruled class and lower the “temperature” of the conflict between the classes. I truly believe that people desperately don’t prefer to fight, so I think everyone will gladly welcome any sign of hope for peace.