As we all know, nobody finds any value in things made by robots.
Now excuse me while I go drive my human manufactured car on the hand-paved streets into fantasyland.
As we all know, nobody finds any value in things made by robots.
Now excuse me while I go drive my human manufactured car on the hand-paved streets into fantasyland.
AI will never want to be fucked, therefore AI can never create art.
What about ace people?
I think a much more universial example would be that AI will never desire garlic bread
What about porn chatbots you prompted to really want to be fucked? π€
They're faking it.
Literally
Remember, AI cannot hold a copyright. That AI art you created? No you didn't, AI did and it's basically public domain.
Well, its "skill" was built on public domain or via piracy, so its result should be public domain too.
Hell, my interpretation of the "derivative works" clause of GPL stipulates that all llm and genai products should also be gpl.
I'm still convinced that being unable to copyright its output was always part of idea of laundering the stolen data fed in. This way it effectively self sabotages the copyrights of every company and individual using it.
So if I could convince a model to do a frame-by-frame recreation of a specific movie, maybe change a detail here or there, then I could distribute that movie without violating copyright?
No, no, you see AI artists do have intent to impress.
It's just that instead of impressing the girl in art class and maybe bumping genitals, they want to impress the 4chan mob and maybe get up votes.
Art is about creating emotion. AI art does create emotions/feelings (hate, anger, nausea, etc).
So does posting a giant pile of diarrhea.
The standard to qualify as art is very low. The standard to qualify as worth looking at is much higher.
most of the anti AI people are just as annoying as that.
Okay clanker.
Theyβre right though, of course
Prose: Art
Prose ran through a machine : NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO THAT'S NOT HECKING ART!
Fuck the AI companies but come on man.
That's not the same thing at all though? When you provide a prompt to an AI, you're basically just feeding it instructions on what to make. I don't think anyone would ever refer to an instruction manual as art.
AI doesn't "make" anything. It steals. All you get when you prompt an AI, is a poor copy of an original piece that it was trained on. Otherwise, you're completely correct.
I donβt think anyone would ever refer to an instruction manual as art.
Grandma's cookbook?
"Fuck the AI companies but..."
Love it when shills try to make their take seem reasonable.
Color does not matter, said the blind man.
Go listen to Skullgrid
What is it and can I have a link?
It's an album by the prog-metal band "Behold the Arctopus"
And listening to it (or more realistically, reading the lyrics) will convince me of what exactly?
No idea. The guy who suggested you listen to it, seems to think it's the best album ever, tho- considering he named himself after it.
So I will learn about this user at least, but I'm struggling to find the motivation.
Lol I wouldn't bother. Music lyrics rarely translate to real-world action or beliefs. So even if the music says something profound (it doesn't) it's just there to sound artistic, or go with the theme of the music. It's extremely performative.
Well, you were very interested in doing an ad homonim attack on my perception of art, and there are challenging sections in the album skullgrid. Have a listen and see what your perspective on art is like and let me know if you're a deaf man that says "notes don't matter"
If you need to refer to an album to make your argument, you don't have an argument.
And it's not an ad hominem to notice you're saying you can't distinguish between art and slop, it's a restatement of what you've said.
If you need to refer to an album to make your argument, you donβt have an argument.
If I need to defend myself with evidence against baseless ad homonim attacks, I don't have an argument?
to notice youβre saying you canβt distinguish between art and slop
Again, without referring to real world things like intricate albums or shitty paintings made by humans that are overrated, we can't discuss things like that, now can we?
all 48 comments