They aren’t “forced” to do anything. They are choosing to throw money down a black hole.
post
Something it's never done? Tech is notorious for spending more than it earns. See: the Dot Com bubble.
I thought Big Tech loved burning money.
Man, I miss MoviePass... For $9.99/mo, it converted venture capital into something people could directly enjoy by watching as many movies as possible!
It’s fucking bandwagoning. That’s it. That’s all this is. I hope the market destroys them for it.
Wall Street spent years demanding AI investment, then panicked when AI investment showed up on the balance sheet: If Alphabet keeps printing record profits while building the infrastructure for the next decade, this may end up looking more like impatience than prudence. The market loves growth, until it has to pay for it.
That's because the amount of AI investment looks like orders of magnitude more than anyone is willing to pay for AI products.
They were happy about spending billions, but now the bubble is into the trillions and there isn't tens of trillions in market demand to make an investment that big pay off.
That assumes demand is fixed. Historically, the biggest technology shifts created entirely new markets that barely existed beforehand. Almost nobody predicted today’s cloud or app economy from early internet revenue. AI spending could still prove excessive, but current demand is a poor ceiling for what future demand might become.
Current buyers are looking to cut back on spending, rather than dramatically increase. And that's based on current prices which are being subsidised by burning investor money, not the prices they need to charge to make a profit.
Cloud and apps didn't need trillions in investment to still not get off the ground. There isn't really any scenario in which current AI spending doesn't turn out to be excessive.
Maybe, but »excessive investment« and »failed technology« aren’t the same thing: Railroads, fiber optics and the dot com era all burned absurd amounts of capital, yet the infrastructure outlived the investors. AI could follow the same pattern: terrible returns for today’s shareholders, enormous value for tomorrow’s economy.
Yeah, but the AI infrastructure is made out of compute hardware that's going to need replaced in 6 years. Not rails that will still be useable in 50 years.
We aren't building lasting infrastructure other than the actual buildings.
I’d argue the models and software are the real long term assets. GPUs depreciate like any other hardware, but a better training pipeline, inference stack, proprietary data, and a model with millions of paying users can survive multiple hardware generations. The chips are replaceable. The ecosystem and customer relationships are much harder to replicate.
That would certainly be the good ending, I won’t hold my breath for it
"If you build it, they will come" refers to a homemade baseball field in a work of fiction. It's not a valid argument for spending trillions of dollars to support demand that doesn't exist just on the off chance that some day it might.
Lol big tech loves speculating. It's a bubble, and if not now, when? ... Delivering real products is such a pain in the ass.
Turns out it's hard to make money if you don't sell infinite free copies of a product that you only have to produce once.
It will be interesting how this plays out. The only bright spot of the bullshit Trump economy is Wall Street's success and AI investing is what is driving that.
Don't forget Trump has made oil way more expensive. That's a huge favor to the world and the things that live on it!
He's also decimated environmental regulation...so, definitely not a huge favour.
Only in the USA. Which is only part of North America. The world is a big place.
Unfortunately, Trump's walls don't contain pollution, and industries use that local lack of regulation to lobby other governments, as in, "look, we can do that in the US, why can't we do it here?"
Only thing they are forced to do is benefit the shareholders.
Never use words like “never” and “always” because things are not always that absolute.
Unless you’re talking about death cause that MFr ain’t never waking up.

top 50 comments