Is it possible to view files in the root of the vault?
Also, is it possible to show non .md files?
My use case for the second question is that I have .pdf and .xml that acompanies my notes. Having HelixEditor showing them as well (or opening them in system default editor) would be nice.
What is about obsidian?
If it were me, I'd have chosen a different name to avoid confusion with helix the editor.
Thanks for all the feedback everyone. Just shipped v1.1.0 based on what was reported here today:
If you want to try HelixNotes, be aware it overwrites the front-matter of notes you open (view only, no edit needed).
Hi ArkHost,
Obsidian user here. I tried HelixNotes for a couple of minutes and here's my feedback:
view mode badge). But that opens the linked note in my default .md viewer, not the HelixEditor itself. IMO view-mode should be visually distinct and also work together with source-mode (so I can edit in source mode and then click view-mode to see the rendered note).$ ... $).Failed to acquire LockFile: LockBusy.Feel free to use my feedback however you want, or don't. Personally, there's more than one deal-breaker for me to switch from Obsidian to HelixNotes, without even considering the nice-to-have features added by all the plug-ins. I recommend you to listen to people who are more likely to use your editor than me, or are already using it. I hope my comment doesn't come over too negatively. I tried to give honest feedback why personally I won't use HelixNotes anytime soon. I wish you all the best.
Appreciate the honest feedback, doesn't come over negatively at all, this is exactly what helps improve the app.
HelixNotes isn't trying to be a replacement for Obsidian. It was a replacement for Obsidian for me, but different people have different needs. Thanks for taking the time.
You even overwrite previously existing front-matters. From just looking at a note. This is a fucking no-go! Luckily I was able to revert all the unwanted changes HelixNotes applied to my vault.
This is a warning for everyone who wants to try HelixNotes with an existing vault.
The import dialog warns you to make a backup before running as it modifies files in place. That said, the frontmatter overwrite on just viewing a note is a valid bug. I'll fix that, notes should only be modified when you actually edit them.
Note taking App, AI in the front page... I don't think you understand the point of taking notes.
AI is optional, disabled by default, and doesn't even show in the UI unless you enable it. The app works fully offline with zero AI involvement.
AI writing tools — improve, summarize, translate, and more (Anthropic / OpenAI)
why though
Fair question. Use case: you take rough notes during a meeting, no formatting, just raw thoughts. AI can clean them up, summarize, or restructure after the fact. It's completely optional though. Disabled by default, doesn't even show in the context menus unless you explicitly configure it in settings with your own API key. If you don't want it, it's like it doesn't exist.
So, a feature for those who want it, but turned off out of the box for those who absolutely do not want it? Did I understand correctly?
Exactly. Off by default, invisible unless you enable it.
As ai features should be. You're the dev?
Correct. Yes I am.
Cool. I appreciate this design decision. If only more went that route (looking at you, Microslop)
Not to be confused with helix the TUI text editor
That was gonna be my question.
Correct, this has nothing to do with the helix TUI text editor in any way.
Notix. Notes + helix avoid confusion with the other app, Notix
Oh hey I’ve been looking for “obsidian but with version history “ for a bit now.
What does it do that obsidian doesn't? Why would I switch? Genuinely interested.
Obsidian's default editor is barebones, you need plugins to get a usable experience. HelixNotes gives you rich editing out of the box: formatting toolbar, slash commands, source mode toggle. No setup. It's also not Electron. Rust + Tauri 2.0 & Svelte fraction of the RAM, launches instantly. Same philosophy though: local .md files, no cloud, no lock-in. If Obsidian works for you, no reason to switch.
Your website says "No sync. No lock-in. No bullshit"
Would you mind elaborating on the thought there? Why no sync?
I use obsidian with self hosted live sync, my notes are mine and they live on my hardware, but they are always in sync between my devices. If I'm on my desktop and take notes, I can pull them up on my laptop or even my phone. With this, I can't reference my notes (or update them) until I'm back on my desktop.
The line "No sync. No lock-in. No bullshit" tells me you're opposed to it on principal, meaning you don't intend to ever add the ability to sync, and that's a nonstarter for me and a lot of people I image. I'd love to migrate from obsidian to something open source, and I'd love to potentially spend time working on contributing a self hosted live sync like feature, but I need to know if my work and pull request will be immediately rejected on a principal I'm not sure I understand?
Good question. "No sync" means no built-in cloud sync - not that sync is impossible. Your notes are plain .md files in a folder, so you can sync them with Syncthing, Nextcloud, rsync, Git, or anything else you already use. The app watches the filesystem for external changes and picks them up automatically.
The philosophy is: I don't decide where your files go. You do.
As for contributions - absolutely welcome. PRs won't be rejected on principle. If you want to work on a self-hosted sync feature, open an issue on Codeberg and let's discuss the approach first. I'd love to see it.
Are there plans for mobile apps? In particular, obsidian and nextcloud don't seem to work well together on android. Changes made to files via obsidian don't get picked up by nextcloud unless I manually go sync the file. This might just be nextcloud's app dropping the ball.
I assume you could use syncthing to sync the notes.
Does this have anything to do with the Helix text editor?
I just downloaded. Looks amazing. I will try it out. Do you have a Patreon Page or something?
Thanks! No Patreon yet, but I'll set something up. For now, the best support is feedback and bug reports.
So far it has been smooth sailing. But I will report. Only things Iam missing are:
maybe you can consider these for the future.
Great! Thanks for the feedback.
All 3 enhancements noted. Will be implemented in next release.
Update: The line shortcuts and line numbers will be in the next release. The side-by-side/split view requires a significant architecture refactor, so that one will take longer - it's on the roadmap but not for the immediate next release.
Wow, that was really fast. Thank you very much!
I need my notes with me. I use SiYuan and I’m more than happy
A place to share alternatives to popular online services that can be self-hosted without giving up privacy or locking you into a service you don't control.
Rules:
Be civil: we're here to support and learn from one another. Insults won't be tolerated. Flame wars are frowned upon.
No spam posting.
Posts have to be centered around self-hosting. There are other communities for discussing hardware or home computing. If it's not obvious why your post topic revolves around selfhosting, please include details to make it clear.
Don't duplicate the full text of your blog or github here. Just post the link for folks to click.
Submission headline should match the article title (don’t cherry-pick information from the title to fit your agenda).
No trolling.
No low-effort posts. This is subjective and will largely be determined by the community member reports.
Resources:
Any issues on the community? Report it using the report flag.
Questions? DM the mods!