Debating on these two laptops… thoughts/opinions??
this post was submitted on 20 Nov 2023
0 points (50.0% liked)
Apple
69 readers
1 users here now
A place for Apple news, rumors, and discussions.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I was at the Apple Store today and gave these a test drive.
The 15" feels way more lighter, it's a great size when closed, super thin. It's the better choice if you the majority of your usage is surfing+light productivity work. Battery life is also a winner because it's not as powerful with just 8 cores. I also love how there is absolutely no fans. Passive heatsink. Will throttle when you really push it.
The 14" definitely felt heaver, thicker. More powerful and I expect it to also not be as a long lasting battery because of the high refresh rate display, more CPU and GPU cores. It's the better laptop if you are going to be doing more than just surfing+light productivity, and you are doing those tasks more often. Video editing, music production, xCode, I would classify as tasks that definitely take advantage of a MBP features. If those are those types of things one does daily, the weight and thickness and can totally be overlooked as the non pro M2 can struggle, I've read anecdotally. MBP also have the better heat dissipation as it has a cooling fan. You want power, you will get it. But also moving parts like a fan will be the first to go on a computer.
The displays are only 1" different. It was like a 50/50, no clear winner.
My personal pick is I chose the 15" simply because of the weight and how thin it is. I have way more powerful computers that I can RDP into. So the MBA serves as the perfect thin client.
15” air is 3.3 lbs, 14” pro is 3.5 lbs. For pure weight they’re very very close.
If both of them are presented in front of you, you lift one up and weight the other, it's immediate that the MBA is subjectively lighter.
But if one purchased the MBP without having touched the MBA, the weight is actually a non-issue. Its not an everyday occurrence to have access to both that it would make a true difference.
Just like how the display is very very close that it could be negligible, as to your point, the weight could be negligible too.
agreed. This is what people dont get it. They just look at specs and say both are same weight but 15" Air will feel substantially lighter than 14" MBP.
This is because all of the weight of the 14" MBP is at the top sector near the display hinge due to fans and other components. The weight is not evenly spreaded out unlike the 15" or 13" air. People just dont get this stuff without carrying and holding them side by side.