this post was submitted on 01 Jul 2023
3 points (100.0% liked)
Feddit UK
1349 readers
1 users here now
Community for the Feddit UK instance.
A place to log issues, and for the admins to communicate with everyone.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I'm so glad this place is here, I was banned from the reddit UK subs for making pro republican statements when Phil died and then when the Queen died I questioned the mods burying of the Republic arrest story and was perma banned.
It wasn't just the reddit API stuff, the way the moderation works is awful, just perma ban you for nothing, I had an account 8 year old and it was perma banned from the sub I posted in most in an instant at the whim of some pro royalist moderator. There's no way to appeal, they also mute you and that's it.
I have a theory that reddit mods always end up bad because the system makes them that way. Dealing with a huge number of bots, fakers, manipulators and that's before you get to the genuine-but-lazy rule breakers.
Maybe, I can understand that, we're all human.
Personally, I think perma banning should not be possible in most cases, maybe just increase the maximum ban time with each ban, or have a ban expire after 12 months. That way at least the account doesn't just become useless to you because of one dickhead mod.
Hopefully lessons will be learned for this platform! :)
With disenfranchisement it's probably an even bigger problem here. Who swathes of users being cut off through no fault of their own other than which site they created an account on.
How do you mean, I am new to this?
I'm new to so still getting to grips. As I understand it, users from different sites in the fediverse have access to others and can share content when federated. Just like I'm on FMHY at Lemmy and you're on feddit.uk, we can still interact on feddit.uk because they're federated. The owner of feddit.uk could decide tomorrow to split from FMHY and I'd still see posts and comments but you wouldn't see my comment here(those in FMHY would see me though). I'd effectively be banned (or in read only mode I suppose) even if the action wasn't taken against me directly.
From what I understand, this is the case between Lemmy.world and BeeHaw at the moment which are 2 of the largest collection of users. The .world users can read BeeHaw and interact with each other there but not with users outside of Lemmy.world.
The admin here has said he'll use defederation sparingly. Also Beehaw defederating lemmy.world is only temporary while they get their house in order.
It will happen but only against instances that have a real bot problem. In general I wouldn't worry about this.
In both cases I fully expect that and entirely understand the BeeHaw admin decision, to the point I've thought about moving myself as I've seen a few posts already that make me uncomfortable. I wasn't critiquing it, was just highlighting that "one dickhead mod" actions having a much larger potential impact here in the Fediverse compared to somewhere like Reddit where you'd lost access to only one sub (or a handful in the case of massive dickhead super mods)