I think Alan Wake 2 is in my top 5 of all time. Gameplay isn't anything special - at least the combat (it's a competent but ordinary survival horror) but the story, presentation, cinematics, mixed media and in general just the art aspects are all top shelf.

It also is the culmination of the Remedyverse stuff, and really pays you off for having played all the preceding games (including Max Payne and Quantum Break).