This is an interesting take, because I assume you don't know the context of what the person you responded to was referencing?

No, i'm fully aware of the context. I unironically think it's a perfectly fine idea and that the people clowning on it are just pissed that it's girly cozy aesthetics instead of cocaine divorced guy aesthetics, which is not sufficient to infer anything about its quality, artistic merit, originality or politics. It's 100% just Gamer misogyny that people get so upset about it. When i can play a game about a fucking cop who has stalked his ex so badly he can dial her new phone number from muscle memory and appreciate the finished product as one of the best video game stories of all time, i can expect guys to not piss their birthday boy pants when a game looks like an episode of the Heidi anime.

Pretty much, yes. Bavaria is unironically the Texas of Germany and if the game is set in Switzerland, Austria, Liechtenstein or South Tirol, the nazi villagers may even be worse. Being a witch in that tradcath-fash setting would allow for a ton of interesting politics, especially if the witch is gay enough.

Or maybe it would just be bucolic mountain stream propaganda. Also possible.

There's no way to tell just from one twitter post. My point is, we shouldn't write an idea like that off just because it sounds like the description of a lo fi beats to study to thumbnail.