Antinatalism
I have this (white) friend from
who seems to be rather antinatalist. I'm on good terms with him, and he has shifted a lot overall since I first got to know him. He was a bit more libby at first, but over time, he's gotten more into Marxism-Leninism and has taken my theory recommendations seriously. Overall, we agree on a lot of things and have a good deal of shit in common, but where I especially have disagreements with him is on the subject of antinatalism.
I find it interesting. He says he's not too deeply invested in it, but he believes that procreation is inherently "selfish and exploitative" and he is always going to feel judgmental towards those who desire kids and those who have kids. He has no desire to see bodily autonomy actively policed, but he thinks that procreation is unethical and, unless done by accident, inherently comes from an exploitative mentality.
Antinatalism is a subject I've thought about a lot because it's a good subject to engage with if you wanna dissect philosophy just for the sake of dissecting philosophy, I guess, but obviously, antinatalism is not gonna actually have any real-world, material relevance, and even he seems to be aware of this.
That being said, the viewpoint still bugs me a bit. I wonder if I should talk to him to see if he's willing to get why it does not make sense and how it's even counterrevolutionary. Marxism and antinatalism cannot coexist because antinatalism has no place within how Marxism handles dialectics. Like I said, it will forever have no material relevance, and, in the way it typically manifests, sometimes overtly and sometimes covertly, it can come with racist, ableist, and eugenicist implications.
He is self-admittedly a tad bit undereducated on the subject of Marxism, so he is still learning. I wonder if this is a connection I can expect him to make on his own.


