this post was submitted on 16 Apr 2024
635 points (98.8% liked)
RPGMemes
10339 readers
565 users here now
Humor, jokes, memes about TTRPGs
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The problem is players are often idiots.
Like, they'll just forget key facts.
"We think Bob did the murders!"
"You mean Bob, the accountant, who was with you when the first murder happened and has rock solid alibis for the second?"
"...yes"
"ok. How do you explain those two things?"
"... nevermind "
Or like, "we think he's a shape shifter!"
"So remember in session 0 we established this is a modern day, no magic, realistic setting?"
"...no."
"Ok, well, we did, and it's in the setting document pinned in the channel. Shape shifters don't fall under realistic, modern day, no magic, so they don't exist in this game."
"...oh."
I was wondering for a quick minute there why you'd play in a physical channel before I remembered that not everyone is as privileged and lucky to play in person all the time.
My players once almost killed a cleaner because he had the same first name as the bad guy.
Reminds me of in DM of the Rings, when they thought they won after killing Saruman.
Something like that. They found out the villains first name, which wasn't exactly uncommon. Asked a guard whether they new anyone by that name, and since they managed to be pretty charming, the guard was like, yeah sure, I know a dude with that first name. Wasn't even related to the story in any way. Just some dude.
I probably would have had them mention a few people with that name, just to make sure they know you're not abiding by the One-Steve Limit.
Realistic and no magick is an oxymoron
Are you making a joke that didn't land, or did you mean redundant?
You can have a game that's "realistic, except for...".
Neither of the above. Reality contains magick. Reality doesn't work without magick. The premise presented is impossible.
Most people do not accept that reality contains magic(k). The post was written from that perspective.