The correct method of sorting is by randomly assigning each book a unique identifier that only you are aware of and organizing by that.

It's like the Dewey decimal system but more creative.

I like the first-in-last-out sort method. I mentally order the shelves from top-to-bottom, left-to-right, like one long linear list of books. As I pick books off the shelf and read them, I always put them back at the top left of the book case, and shift the rest to the right and down as needed. Then I see my favorite or recently read books in one location, and books I've never even touched at the bottom.