Well, I'm open to other interpretations in general. There's room for that, despite the Wilder Wonka being impossible to beat.

I didn't hate Charlie and the chocolate factory, though that's mostly because it was a movie of the book rather than a new version of the movie.

And, I like chalumet (however it's spelled). He's done some good work. So I'm not against the idea of him doing it.

It's what you said, it feels like a cash grab rather than a genuine attempt at making a new movie. Those so rarely end well. And, if it sucks as bad as I fear, it kinda t aints the story itself; it would be harder for someone else to do a new movie based on the book in the future (I still maintain that the Wilder movie wasn't meant to be a true translation of the book, and the Depp movie failed at that despite trying). I'd like to see a truly faithful translation of the book.