you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 19 points 1 day ago (5 children)

The Catholic church is a lot of things. Going from writing Rerum Novarum, calling for essentially dramatic limits put on capitalism to curb wealth inequality and put the responsibility of societal wellbeing on the wealthy, and Sicut Dudum, calling for the release of the enslaved people of the Canary Islands and to give them the opportunity to willingly be baptized instead of theough deception and force, which in 1435 is wildly progressive of a stance to take, and Pacem in Terris calling for nuclear disarmament to Magnificas Humanitas calling for limits on AI.

Then theres the crusades and the centuries of European kingmaking and mediating treaties that all collapsed in and resulted in all the wars in Europe for over a millennium up to and including WW1 and in the present day the rampant pedophilia problem to holding generally anti-gay stances.

Sometimes its kinda progressive, sometimes its wildly conservative. Gun to head, forced to choose some flavor of Christianity, I'd rather go with the Catholics than any of the American Evangelical Protestant denominations. The pedo shit is still pedo shit but that's not unique to Catholicism, that's "an institution with power attracting predators" problem and there is a lot of unaccounted for history that they are responsible for.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 9 hours ago (2 children)

    Going from writing Rerum Novarum, calling for essentially dramatic limits put on capitalism to curb wealth inequality and put the responsibility of societal wellbeing on the wealthy

    That's just what they write? What do they actually do? Significantly, most of the main areas of catholicism, like latin america and the Philipines are extremely unequal if anything. I read a study (which I can't find, so feel free to disbelieve me) that said that hierchial religions, like catholicism, correlates with inequality.

    Sicut Dudum, calling for the release of the enslaved people of the Canary Islands and to give them the opportunity to willingly be baptized instead of theough deception and force, which in 1435 is wildly progressive of a stance to take

    Catholicism would later approve of and facilitate slavery in countless other regions, like in the Americas, or approve of the trade of African slaves. Often, they were more brutal in their methods than the Spanish army, or Spanish civilian settlements. Besides, what did that "willingly baptized" even entail, considering that the canary religion is gone now.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 7 hours ago* (1 child)

    Thats why I said Catholicism is a mixed bag of moderately progressive and quite conservative stances. Being one of, if not, the most powerful organization in the world, even just paying lipservice to an issue does cause changes to happen. Yeah in the modern day, the catholic church doesn't wield the same political authority it did during the height of the Middle Ages, so lipservice from them doesnt go nearly as far as it used to.

    Its why I tempered my vaguely positive comments about catholicism with pointing out its history of being pretty central to the centuries of conflict in Europe and in the middle east and the current pedophile problem that it refuses to deal with.

    Vehemently, fuck the catholic church because they attract and harbor pedophiles, fuck them for their centuries of political meddling, fuck them for the crusades. But I also recognize the catholic church isnt going anywhere so I'll do the practical thing and praise the good done and condemn the evils perpetuated.

    Even with all these problems, the catholic church is still a generally better organization that the various evangelical protestant offshoots.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 23 minutes ago

    Even with all these problems, the catholic church is still a generally better organization that the various evangelical protestant offshoots.

    I mean if the best argument you have is that "it isn't the absolute worst option" then you have a pretty flimsy argument. The lesser evil is still fucking evil and should be treated as such.

    There is nothing practical about sane washing something that is intrinsically terrible just because it is relatively better than something else.

  • source
  • parent