Hello everynyan, we're reading Soviet Democracy

Week 2 we are reading chapter 3: "The Rights of the Wage-Earner" and chapter 4: "The Power of the Trade Unions"

EPUB, and link to a PDF, of the book can be found on Comrade's Library. If you find problems with the EPUB tell me and I will fix it.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 5 points 22 hours ago* (2 children)

I don't like the Triangle model.

I think that you should have a party representative who is involved in all decision making to make sure that there is proactive compliance with the laws, principles, and communist doctrine. Effectively we should have the party representative as an accountability officer.

The manager and the union representative should be the same person. Elected by the workers.

A top-down selected manager by the state just enforces hierarchy and may subvert the Democratic workplace process.

Perhaps my philosophies are more anarchist than the USSR.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 15 hours ago

    As you can see in the chapter, even people within the USSR had their complaints about it, it was far from a perfect system, it was an experiment, with positives and negatives, compared to literally anywhere else on earth at the time, it was a massive improvement, but it still needed improving itself, as people noted it resulted in things being somewhat insular and resistant to criticism. Reactions like this are probably why the Chinese communists emphasise "ruthless criticism of all that exists" as a means of preventing the eventual stagnation of the system that this "triangle" was a part of. Once political nihilism had set in in the USSR, there seemed to be little point to even bother criticising, since it seemed like people felt their voices weren't really being heard, and a crop of do-nothing leaders more concerned with being in charge than actually leading ended up isolating people from the system. It certainly wasn't the primary cause of the Soviet stagnation and collapse, but even at this point you can see people noticing the cracks in the system, and wanting them fixed before they become a problem (instead the later Soviet leaders seemed more focused on making them worse, deliberately or not).

    It's an important lesson to learn I think from this. A similar system could work well in the early stages of a socialist state, but it would need to be phased out once people no longer have a "capitalist mentality" and no longer view their fellow workers as a threat or competition. Just as socialism is a transitional state, it also has lots of transitions within itself.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 4 points 20 hours ago*

    In a general sense, I think it depends on how economic planning is handled. If it's somewhat loose planning, with relatively more market mechanisms, you can let each enterprise do its own thing, entirely under its own self-management, as long as its compliant with whatever laws/regulations/mandates apply. But if production is more tightly integrated across enterprises, more directly coordinated across the economy, it makes sense to have more management input from the state and/or the party in some form. And that could potentially vary between industries, based on eg. the complexity of their supply chains.

    It sounded like co-ops were used to an extent, I assume operating how you describe, but not much detail on that so far. (That's the next chapter & I haven't read it yet)

    The triangle model seems reasonable based on the short overview given, but I have a lot of questions about what responsibilities map onto which 'side' & how this functioned in practice.

  • source
  • parent