you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 3 points 4 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago) (3 children)

That’s probably why these fash weirdos are pumping the ROTS novelization

I bet they just heard that it's an actual good book (sort of true, terms and conditions apply) and namedrop it so people might associate them with quality.

the idea that he’s still carrying unresolved trauma from being enslaved carries nearly all that weight

And like his time as a slave didn't even seem all that bad, he looked like a clean and well fed kid who had time to pursue engineering as a hobby and would nerd out about local sport events.

The shape of the story feels like Anakin was aged down late in development and he was meant to cut a more harrowing figure as both a run down victim of generational slavery as well as a target of racism/speciesism all too eager to prove himself (wasn't there a thing where the other kids were being demeaning to him about humans being too slow in the head to be good pod racers), and also old enough to catch similarly aged Amidala's eye, instead of inadvertently turning her into a creep who ogles grade schoolers. And the jedi wouldn't need to pretend that you must be like months old to start training otherwise it might not take, which implicitly turns them into baby snatchers.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 4 hours ago

    The shape of the story feels like Anakin was aged down late in development and he was meant to cut a more harrowing figure as both a run down victim of generational slavery as well as a target of racism/speciesism all too eager to prove himself

    I've never thought of it this way, but that does in fact make the most sense. Lucas swerved at the last minute to make Episode 1 a kiddy movie? I can't imagine he would have needed to do that to secure funding for the then long-awaited continuation of Star Wars, but stranger things have happened.

    wasn’t there a thing where the other kids were being demeaning to him about humans being too slow in the head to be good pod racers

    Yes, this is a pretty critical plot point, Anakin can only participate as a human because he can use the Force.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 1 point 3 hours ago

    I remember seeing Star Wars for the first time in '78 or something (we lived in Malaysia at the time and I believe it took some time to get there). I was dead center in the marketing targetting. And for a while I was dying to know about the Clone Wars and what Luke's father was doing there.

    God, Ep 1 was such a let-down.

    I believe there are 2 kinds of nerds - those that accept that there will just be mentions of the lore and it's basically flavor, and those that just need to know and explore the lore down to the last minutae. Let me tell you, the image I had of the Clone Wars as an 8 year old was way fucking cooler than what appeared in Ep 2. And Vader?? Please let me keep my personal backstory.

  • source
  • parent