If I learned anything, it's that these things are inconsistent as fuck. I have a few legit ones that wouldn't pass all these tests either 🫠. For example, they do charge from wall sockets depending on the adapter used to plug them in. The spacing/location of the printed texts are also off sometimes. And I also got them in both 5V/500A and 3.7V/300A (both EU ones).
But they where bought new from reputable stores by me or people I knew back in the day, some even came with the console. Definitly legit controllers.
Most of mine are European versions, which also come in many varierities. Half of them I haven't found documented on sites like VGCollect. One is an American one.
Either way, it makes it hard to judge realness for sure. Other than obvious fakes, I haven't found a perfect way to tell for sure without tracing back the specific controllers origin. I never opened them up tho, so that might be more clear.












