Hello everynyan, we're reading This Soviet World.

Week 5 we are reading Chapter 5: "The Union of Nations."

EPUB, a link to a PDF, and online reading options, can be found on Comrade's Library. If you find problems with the EPUB tell me and I will fix it. Dessalines has made an audio book.


Previous discussions:

Week 4 - Week 3 - Week 2 - Week 1


ⓘ This user is suspected of being a cat. Please report any suspicious behavior.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 11 points 2 months ago (1 child)

The discussion we had last time about the uhh..."outdated" language is on full display here. Still, you can tell she means well and I love how she makes sure to emphasise just how much all of the different cultures and nations of the Soviet union were able to help each other, not just with help from the "Russians" but by all of them coming together to build a better future.

I found this quote interesting though:

If we should claim that the Jews are a chosen people, the best and brainiest in the world, that’s nationalism. It’s dangerous nonsense, the kind of murderous nonsense that leads Turks to attack Armenians or white Americans to lynch Negroes. The assertion of the right of one culture to dominate another, or even to pre-eminence—that is the capitalist wish to exploit, and it leads to war. We have no right to exploit or to claim pre-eminence; but we have the same rights as others to develop our own characteristic culture in peace.

At this time Western Europe was trying to settle Jewish colonists in the middle east, if I remember correctly, so a lot of Jewish people globally could probably see that same sort of fascist nationalism developing within their own societies.

It really is sad how little things have ultimately actively changed in the world from almost a century ago. When she talks about the claims of the fascists, those sections could literally be written today, capital hasn't changed in the slightest.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 8 points 2 months ago

    The whiplash for me reading is just how timeless her analysis of capitalist societies are. My takeaway from this chapter was that this history was so successfully wiped from western/neoliberal education that capitalist nations can actually claim that the USSR was actually oppressing these nations rather than emancipating them.

  • source
  • parent