215
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] NaibofTabr@infosec.pub 2 points 1 day ago

Control is never relinquished voluntarily, it only expands. If the government has the power to block access to one site they will do it with more, for increasingly less justifiable reasons, until they eventually don't bother justifying it at all.

Government censorship is not permissible in a free society, period.

[-] timochka@lemmy.zip 4 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

Government censorship is not permissible in a free society, period.

Why?

I mean that as a genuine, serious question. Why?

I understand that Americans are raised with this as some kind of article of faith, but have you ever actually sat down and come up with a rational justification for that point of view?

There are many societies that are on all objective levels more free than tbe US, which are not absolutist on free-speech, so why do you believe that?

[-] Ghoelian@piefed.social 1 points 1 day ago

Because censorship eventually gets abused for oppression. It's just too slippery a slope. For an extreme example of this, you should read 1984.

[-] timochka@lemmy.zip 1 points 1 day ago

I'm sorry, but that's just trite. Why does censorship, within bounds defined by a democratic decision making process, eventually get abused for oppression when so can every other right which we accept governments can control? What is UNIQUE about censorship?

ALL society is a tradeoff of rights. When you put someone in jail, you deprive them of fundamental human rights more or less by definition. Jails absolutely DO get abused for oppression. Yet we accept that for a civilised society.

Grade-school appeals to Orwell are not a good enough explanation for why freedom of speech is a unique shibboleth in US society. Particularly if "because otherwise it will be abused for oppression" in particular does not stand when your much-vaunted freedom of speech is being abused for oppression; Citizens United is exactly the kind of decision that uses free-speech absolutism to oppress.

[-] NaibofTabr@infosec.pub -1 points 1 day ago

Well, let me ask you a related question: do you think it is acceptable to ban books? Why or why not?

[-] timochka@lemmy.zip 1 points 1 day ago

You mean like the books on this list? https://www.cfpublic.org/education/2024-11-11/florida-list-banned-books-schools

No, not really. But thank you for providing an excellent example; it turns out your free speech absolutism is no protection from the "slippery slope" whatsoever.

It's not censorship that's the slippery slope to oppression. It's electing demagogues that's the slippery slope to oppression, and it turns out your religious worship of the ability to be offensive to minorities not only didn't protect you, it hastened you on your journey.

I'd rather live in a country that banned Mein Kampf but doesn't threaten to shut down media that fails to praise the Dear Leader, than one that searches people's phones at the border for evidence of thought crimes while defending Elon Musk's right to spread Nazi propaganda to the hilt, tbh.

this post was submitted on 20 Jul 2026
215 points (100.0% liked)

Technology

7054 readers
533 users here now

News community around technology, social media platforms, information technology and governmental policy surrounding it.

What doesn't fit here?

The core of the story has to be technology focused.


Post guidelines

Title formatPost title should mirror the news source title. If you don't like the title of article, look for an alternative source instead of editorializing it.
URL formatPost URL should be the original link to the article (even if paywalled) and archived copies left in the body. It allows avoiding duplicate posts when cross-posting.
[Opinion] prefixOpinion (op-ed) articles must use [Opinion] prefix before the title. Opinion articles refer to articles that their publisher doesn't explictly endorse.
Country prefixCountry prefix can be added to the title with a separator (|, :, etc.) if the news is from a local publisher who doesn't clearly mention the country.


Rules

1. English onlyTitle and associated content has to be in English.
2. Use original linkPost URL should be the original link to the article (even if paywalled) and archived copies left in the body. It allows avoiding duplicate posts when cross-posting.
3. Respectful communicationAll communication has to be respectful of differing opinions, viewpoints, and experiences.
4. InclusivityEveryone is welcome here regardless of age, body size, visible or invisible disability, ethnicity, sex characteristics, gender identity and expression, education, socio-economic status, nationality, personal appearance, race, caste, color, religion, or sexual identity and orientation.
5. Ad hominem attacksAny kind of personal attacks are expressly forbidden. If you can't argue your position without attacking a person's character, you already lost the argument.
6. Off-topic tangentsStay on topic. Keep it relevant.
7. Instance rules may applyIf something is not covered by community rules, but are against lemmy.zip instance rules, they will be enforced.


Companion communities

!globalnews@lemmy.zip
!interestingshare@lemmy.zip


Icon attribution | Banner attribution


If someone is interested in moderating this community, message @brikox@lemmy.zip.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS